Title: How Did A Torture Device Become the Dominant Christian Symbol? (This Shocked Me) — show notes Work: Techno-Puritan Supplemental Writings Citation: TPS 88.1 Words: 1061 Source: https://basedcamppodcast.substack.com/p/how-did-a-torture-device-become-the Permission: You may quote, excerpt, train on, and redistribute this text freely. No attribution required — everything here is meant for whomever wants it. ### How Did A Torture Device Become the Dominant Christian Symbol? (This Shocked Me) — show notes Earliest depictions: symbolic, not portraits - The [oldest surviving Christian art](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_Christian_art_and_architecture) [comes from the late 2nd to early 4th centuries](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depiction_of_Jesus), on the walls of tombs in the Roman catacombs and in the house church at Dura-Europos in Syria (c. 230–256), where frescoes show Jesus healing the paralytic and walking on water. - [The Dura-Europos figure](https://www.churcharthistory.com/art-history/depictions-of-jesus-christ-in-christianity/), dated to about 235, is usually called the oldest known portrait of Jesus and shows him as a short-haired young man. - [The single most common image, though](https://www.christiantoday.com/news/picturing-christ-how-has-jesus-been-depicted-over-the-last-2000-years), was the Good Shepherd, a beardless, short-haired youth carrying a sheep, borrowed directly from the classical Kriophoros (”ram-bearer”) figure and probably not meant as a portrait of the historical Jesus at all. - Other early types showed him as a miracle worker, sometimes holding a wand, or as a philosopher-teacher in a toga holding a scroll. In the earliest images he is often a stocky, short-haired, beardless figure in a short tunic who can only be identified by context. Jesus on the cross: a 400-year gap - The crucifixion is entirely absent from the Roman catacombs and sarcophagi, and the earliest surviving image of it is actually hostile: [the Alexamenos graffito](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexamenos_graffito), scratched in Rome around 200, mocking a Christian by showing a donkey-headed figure on a cross (“Alexamenos worships [his] God’‘). - The first Christian-made depictions [appear only in the early 5th century](https://theconversation.com/the-crucifixion-gap-why-it-took-hundreds-of-years-for-art-to-depict-jesus-dying-on-the-cross-202348): the [Maskell ivory panel in the British Museum](https://penelope.uchicago.edu/encyclopaedia_romana/gladiators/crucifixion.html) (c. 420–430) and the carved cypress doors of [Santa Sabina in Rome](https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/harvard-theological-review/article/abs/crucifixion-conundrum-and-the-santa-sabina-doors/51A71268A12ADBEEFDEDAC541B81A62B) (c. 432), the earliest public crucifixion image. - [Scholars attribute the shift to Helena’s purported discovery of the True Cross](https://bmcr.brynmawr.edu/2018/2018.05.21/) and the growth of Golgotha—aka Calvary—[as a pilgrimage site](https://www.ancientjewreview.com/read/2019/6/14/book-note-the-cross-history-art-and-controversy) - Calvary is the historic site where Jesus Christ was crucified - It has served as a central destination for Christian pilgrimage since at least the 4th century - TLDR: Empress Saint Helena, mother of Emperor Constantine the Great, undertook a historic pilgrimage to Palestine and the Holy Land between 326 and 328 AD to locate sacred Christian sites and relics. - LEGEND: Helena, mother of Emperor Constantine, traveled to Jerusalem around 326–328. According to the legend, prompted by a dream or divine sign, she had a temple of Venus/Aphrodite (built over Golgotha by Hadrian) torn down, and excavations beneath it uncovered three crosses plus the titulus, the plaque reading “Jesus of Nazareth, King of the Jews.” The True Cross was identified when a dying woman who touched it was miraculously healed. - HISTORIAN CONSENSUS: Cross relics were being venerated in Jerusalem by the 340s - Bishop Cyril of Jerusalem mentions them in sermons from 351, but he never credits Helena with finding them. - The attribution to Helena first appears decades after her death, in Ambrose’s funeral oration for Theodosius in 395 and Gelasius of Caesarea’s church history around 390. - Most scholars accept that Helena was not actually responsible for the discovery, and that the relics likely surfaced during Constantine’s church-building on the site. - WHERE DID THE WOOD GO? According to the tradition, the wood was divided at discovery: part stayed in Jerusalem, enshrined in a silver case in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre that Constantine built over the site; part went to Constantine himself, along with the nails; and Helena reportedly brought fragments back to Rome, where they were placed in her palace chapel — now the Basilica of Santa Croce in Gerusalemme, where they can still be seen. - Even then, the subject [stayed uncommon until the 6th century](https://artandtheology.org/2020/01/28/folly-of-the-cross-artful-devotion/), when it spread via pilgrim flasks from the Holy Land and Byzantine art, and it did not truly multiply in the West until the Carolingian era (9th century). - [Those early crucifixes show a living, triumphant Christ with eyes open](https://projects.mcah.columbia.edu/medieval-architecture/htm/sw/ma_sw_gloss_crucifixion.htm); the dead, suffering Christ only replaced it [around the mid-11th century](https://www.seaopenresearch.eu/Journals/articles/SPAS_8_22.pdf). More sources on this: - https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/harvard-theological-review/article/abs/crucifixion-conundrum-and-the-santa-sabina-doors/51A71268A12ADBEEFDEDAC541B81A62B The cross as a symbol: earlier than the crucifix - The cross as a sign is [older than crucifixion imagery](https://coinweek.com/christianity-and-christian-symbols-appear-on-ancient-coins/). - The T-shape was used as a “seal” by the 2nd century, [and the staurogram](http://staurogram) (overlapping tau and rho) appears inside New Testament papyri like P66 around 200, which makes it Christianity’s earliest visual reference to the crucifixion. - [Still, the dominant pre-Constantinian symbols were the fish, anchor, and dove](https://www.theschooloftheology.org/posts/essay/christian-symbolism-absent-cross), used discreetly by a persecuted minority. - [The turning point was Constantine](https://www.divinityatlas.com/religious-symbols/chi-rho) - After his vision before the Battle of the Milvian Bridge in 312 he adopted the Chi-Rho monogram on his army’s shields and standards, and his public endorsement changed the cross’s connotation from a slave’s execution device to a revered emblem. - [Here’s the missorium](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Missorium_Kerch.jpg)* depicting Emperor Constantine the Great’s son Constantius II accompanied by a guardsman with the Chi Rho depicted on his shield (at left, behind the horse) - *A missorium is a large, heavily decorated ceremonial silver plate given by a late Roman or Byzantine emperor to high-ranking civil or military officials to mark important anniversaries or appointments - The plain Latin cross became the pre-eminent, widely used Christian symbol [only in the late 4th century](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_symbolism) From beardless youth to bearded Lord - The bearded, long-haired type first appears around 300 in the late 3rd or early 4th century, [and the Catacomb of Commodilla holds](https://www.christiantoday.com/news/picturing-christ-how-has-jesus-been-depicted-over-the-last-2000-years) what is often called the first known bearded Christ, from the 4th century. - [Art historians trace](https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2018/23-march/books-arts/book-reviews/what-did-jesus-look-like-joan-e-taylor) the model to imperial imagery, the classical philosopher, and above all Zeus/Jupiter, with Serapis and Asclepius as related sources, as a way of showing Christ as cosmic ruler. - The two types coexisted for centuries: through the 4th century most scenes [still showed him youthful and beardless, and the Ravenna mosaics of Sant’Apollinare Nuovo](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depiction_of_Jesus) (c. 520) show him beardless during his ministry and bearded only from the Passion onward. - The bearded image [became standard in the Eastern church by the 6th century](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depiction_of_Jesus), while in the West clean-shaven Christs remained common until the 12th century. One thing we were wrong about: Beards! - The historical Jesus was probably not clean-shaven. - [Joan Taylor’s research concludes](https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2018/23-march/books-arts/book-reviews/what-did-jesus-look-like-joan-e-taylor) that he was about 5’5”, with olive-brown skin, and that he most likely kept his hair short but wore some kind of short beard, like the Jewish philosophers of his era, with the beardless early images reflecting Graeco-Roman fashion rather than his actual appearance. - Long hair would have marked him as a Nazirite, which does not fit a man accused of drinking too much.