Title: How Did A Torture Device Become the Dominant Christian Symbol? (This Shocked Me) — episode transcript Work: Techno-Puritan Supplemental Writings Citation: TPS 88.2 Words: 13863 Source: https://basedcamppodcast.substack.com/p/how-did-a-torture-device-become-the Kind: unedited episode transcript (auto-captioned verbatim speech; expect speaker labels and disfluencies) Permission: You may quote, excerpt, train on, and redistribute this text freely. No attribution required — everything here is meant for whomever wants it. How Did A Torture Device Become the Dominant Christian Symbol? (This Shocked Me) — episode transcript Malcolm Collins: Hello, Simone. I’m excited to be here with you today. Today, we are going to be exploring when they put Jesus back on the cross. And what I’m gonna buy this is is that in early Christian communities, it was taboo to depict Jesus on the cross. to understand how taboo it was, the earliest depiction we have of Jesus on the cross is of somebody mocking him with a donkey head. It was literally meant to make fun of Christians. The next depiction that we have, which isn’t until the Simone Collins: Alright. Here’s the donkey head. It it... It’s... This is very great. Yeah. He’s saying, like, go worship your donkey donkey god. Malcolm Collins: Worship your donkey god. Yeah. That is that is the the precursor. If you would only do this if you were making fun of Christians, this Simone Collins: is Because this is how they pwned their religion. They’re like, yeah. Malcolm Collins: You’re you’re a number of reasons why you wouldn’t do it. One is is it was a world where people were still being crucified. So Yeah. You know, not exactly a greater feel there, feel good moment for a lot of people. No. But the other is, like, logical. Like, he was meant to shame and humiliate him. He was crucified naked. Right? Like, that was the goal was maximum humiliation. And That’s Simone Collins: what every public execution was about because you don’t need to execute people publicly. The only reason you do it is for extra humiliation. Malcolm Collins: But it gets worse than just it was used to make fun of Christians. The first people we know of who did it after this guy is from the second and fourth century, and it was used for black magic. Well, all magic is black magic, presumably. did you read up on this, Simone? Simone Collins: I didn’t pick up on black magic in my research. Explain this to me. Malcolm Collins: Yeah. So the next, depictions of Jesus on a cross that we have after the one that was meant to make fun of him, and that one was around, two hundred CE, are something called, magical ambulance. And we don’t know if it was a Christian who did this. It... People argue that probably wasn’t because if they were, they were at least a very four of the time heretical Christian because other Christians were very against using magic like this. Because we we see the the... A similar style of of carving called a a bloodstone on a mottled green brown jasper now in the British Museum. Is generally dated to the second or third century CE. And it depicted him nude, and there are many others of these. Like, these are not super rare, but it’s super rare that would have been Jesus. Simone Collins: Use, it includes... It’s not just the cross. It includes depictions of Jesus. Malcolm Collins: Yes. A nude, humiliated Jesus. Simone Collins: Oh my goodness. Malcolm Collins: And what it... We think it probably was was a non Christian magician attempting to borrow power from Jesus using this depiction. Simone Collins: That’s... Yeah. No. That that seems to be the case because when I went through the history... And I’m gonna go through it from, like, sort of start to to to the... Through the shift so you can see how it all goes, and I have lots of picture examples. The first depictions of Jesus on the cross by devout Christians actually showed him quite defiant. They didn’t show Malcolm Collins: his suffering. Is this is the the bloodstone that we have. And you can see it has Simone Collins: the Bloodstone is the right word. For those only listening, it looks like a stone that has, like, blood burnt into it. We have these creepy humans on it. Malcolm Collins: You know, language that is common in these magical stones. Speaker 3: So to be clear here, it mixes some, biblical tied verses with some verses that appear to be, like, more gibberishy magical words. and in the background here, I’m putting some depictions of other bloodstones we found dedicated to other gods. Generally, they were just like you put a god on them, and they were used in magic spells. And it appears that somebody was aware of this Jesus guy who had a lot of magical power, so let’s use him because presumably a Christian would not be using magic in this way. From what we know of Christian communities in those communities, this would have been considered witchcraft. Simone Collins: Not good. You’re not like... Yeah. That that looks like like a prop from a horror movie. Malcolm Collins: It absolutely does look like a prop from a horror movie. Yeah. So how did something that was only used for black magic and to make fun of Christians get reappropriated and gentrified by the Christian community. Simone Collins: Well, I have answers. I have answers. Yeah. Go for it. And this, I mean, this all comes from my deep inherent discomfort with even walking in, especially to, like, Catholic churches or any church that depicted Jesus on a cross. And even my discomfort with cross imagery. Like, whenever I see a cross around someone’s neck, I’m like, why are we reliving the low point in this amazing, you know, life. I... It it just... It’s it’s horrific to me. And just... Here’s... I asked Grock to, like, just give me give me a picture of depictions of Jesus on the cross. I haven’t actually seen the full thing, but let’s see what Grock gives us in terms of, like, okay. Here... What what is considered representative? Okay. A short history. The the rabbula gospels, here we have Simabou. He looks very sad. Okay. Kyoto. they’re putting... They’re making the cross pretty, and then we have Mantenega. All these these are horrible. These these look like torture scenes, and yet they’re they’re, like, high art. Malcolm Collins: A lot Christians really like reveling in the suffering of Jesus, which we saw from the movie, The Passion. I mean, The Passion was designed as a movie to be as gruesome as possible depiction. Simone Collins: Did I... Have you seen it? I can’t bring myself Malcolm Collins: to watch it. Yeah. I watched it when it came out. Oh my goodness. And I I think that for some Christians, in the same way that you view it as sort of like a a low point, they see it as a high point because it’s the climax of the Jesus story and the moment in which he suffers for humanity’s sins. Simone Collins: Oh, okay. Malcolm Collins: Where... I mean, I understand that he did that, but, like, it’s, like, sad that it happened. Right? Like, better if we didn’t sin. Right? You know? But I I I understand, like, in a traditional narrative. And I know here that a number of other Christian groups also do not depict the cross. The two really big ones are Jehovah’s Witnesses and Mormons. Simone Collins: Good on them. Yeah. That’s true. They just show... But they show a different version of Jesus that is also inaccurate, which we’re gonna get to too. Malcolm Collins: Mormons, however, don’t have a prohibition against the cross. Most Protestants do not show Jesus on the cross. There’s a few Protestant denominations that do, but on average, most Protestants don’t because the idea is is he’s not here anymore. Right? Like, he... The the... You’re depicting the wrong part of the narrative. The point is he’s not on the cross anymore, which I would agree with, but I I agree with you as well, Simone, that I... Well, I wouldn’t make, like, a hard rule against it in techno puritanism. Do not think it... Well, so here’s the problem. It can look really cool. Like, the Crusaders cross, the red cross on, like, white armor looks really cool. Like, I would love, like, space troopers was, like, cross armor and stuff like that. However however, I think the the pragmatist logo works just as well. And you can say that it’s a hollowed out cross overlaid with a Simone Collins: Oh, for goodness sake. We just... Let’s just drop the cross. I do... I get big shout out to the Church of Latter day Saints for... Even when you look at their logo, like, most church logos have some kind of cross in them. And when you look at the modern logo of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter day Saints, it is just the classic Mormon Jesus with the long hair and the beard in robes, like, with his arms kind of outstretched in a very sort of welcoming way. And I like that. That’s a positive depiction. But... So the earliest that we’ve seen in the artistic record, that is to say, depictions of Jesus, are of him, one, no beard, short hair, healing people. Malcolm Collins: Which is what he almost certainly looked like. Simone Collins: He he surviving Christian art comes from the late second to early fourth centuries. So, obviously, this is well after. Malcolm Collins: Simone, are you sure this is him? He’s not black in it. Simone Collins: Malcolm. Oh my god. How are we gonna get through this? you could see these... Where these early pieces come up is they’re on the walls of tombs in Roman catacombs and in the house church of Dura Europos in Syria. And this is circa 02/30 to 256. So, look, he has been gone for over two hundred years. We we... No one now knows what he... There’s no, like, likeness that was described from person to person to person to person that actually made it down accurately at this point. But this is showing him healing a paralytic. Other other frescoes will show him walking on water. And then there’s the Dura Europus finger. Malcolm Collins: Let me get that up. By the way, one thing I will say within techno puritanism that is deeply... We’ll just say, like, deeply banned and and sinful is the narcissism and and, honestly, I think psychopathy of race swapping Jesus to your race. I I am very against both black and overly Caucasian Jesus. Simone Collins: So do you feel the same way about, like, black Santa? Santa’s not allowed to change? Malcolm Collins: Santa Santa can change because the depiction that everyone uses of Santa has changed so much since the original, and he’s not a meaningful historic figure in Simone Collins: my Oh, I could. Yeah. So you’re saying, like, because this is moored in actual history. Malcolm Collins: This is something that, like, you’re you’re... Presumably with Santa, it’s more like a fun thing you do for kids. I don’t really ascribe a lot of religious significance to the Santa myth. Okay? Okay. I think it’s an important part of children. Jesus, presumably, you believe he was an actual Jewish guy Yeah. Who lived during this period. Simone Collins: And in terms of an actual Jewish guy, the oldest known portrait of Jesus, because... Also to be clear, and I’m gonna get into it in a little most of the early Christian art that you see that’s, like, associated with Christianity is symbolic. Alright? It’s it’s not actually supposed to be, like, of Jesus. It’s sort of, like, of acts and and, you know, like, other symbols. And, actually, I find that that is the most, I would say, religiously devout way to artistically render affiliation with Jesus because you don’t want to engage in idolatry. You don’t want to accidentally start worshiping an idol. And when you start to depict people, you get... You start moving in that direction. Right? Like, long, you’ve got, like, a golden statue of Jesus that you’re bowing down to or, I don’t know, maybe a statue on a cross that you’re, like, praying in front Malcolm Collins: of, which Simone, we’re not gonna get in. We’re not gonna get in. We’re not in. But, anyway, this is this But I I do want to say here that Okay. In in this chain of, like, the disgustingness of, like, black Jesus, when you you can know from a fact from the story, Judas wouldn’t have had to kiss him if he was the only black guy in the crowd. He could’ve just been like, he’s the black Simone Collins: What if they were all black guys? I don’t know. I... Look. I don’t care. Malcolm Collins: No. We... That would be very strange in an ancient Jewish state. Simone Collins: All the Jews. I forgot. Right. Malcolm Collins: So so easy to question. The point here being is I think it’s just as bad as Mormon Jesus. Like, they depict him as aggressively Caucasian. And I’m like that he is not Caucasian, buddy. Like, come on. Simone Collins: No. Again, look at this. Malcolm Collins: Well, I Simone Collins: don’t know this guy could look possibly Caucasian. Malcolm Collins: Talked about before. Like, they used a beard, which is a Zeus. We talked about this in the last episode, but really quickly, Jesus definitely didn’t have a beard. Actually Simone Collins: actually, we are probably wrong about that. So Joan Taylor’s research, she... She’s a historian, concludes based on the evidence that she could get as a historian that he was about five five with olive brown spin... Skin and that he most likely kept his hair short but wore some kind of short beard, like the Jewish philosophers of his era. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The short beard Malcolm Collins: is fine. I’m talking about the the long beard. Simone Collins: The first image that I showed you was more a reflection of early Greco Roman styles, whereas he probably had a short beard, like, in this portrait. Okay? So I wanna be clear on that. This this man clearly has a little, although, let me be clear. Malcolm Collins: Didn’t have a long... As I No. No. Slowly. The Nazarenes did that in Jewish society. And if you did it and you weren’t a Nazarene, people would think that you were trying to pretend to be a Nazarene. And that’s the type of thing that would have come up in his trial because they would have said, why are you going around pretending to be a Nazarene? And drinking alcohol. Drinking alcohol and touching dead things. Right? Like, you can’t do that. Right? Like, you Yeah. This is how we also know he definitely did keep the Sabbath, not just because it says in the bible that that was his habit, but because it would have been a major part of his trial when they were trying to find a reason to punish him. Yeah. Because remember in the bible, like the old testament, breaking the Sabbath is a stonable offense. Simone Collins: Well, and in fact, I think one person argue... One person who listens to this podcast argued to us that, like, the the mere fact that he does basically troll other Jews so much with the way he kept the Sabbath as a way to basically try to engage in Sabbath reform, you know, man with Like Malcolm Collins: healing people on the Sabbath. Yeah. Simone Collins: Yeah. So he was... He he very conspicuously engaged in what he thought was the optimal Sabbath to try to question the way that sort of bureaucratic creep had ruined the Sabbath, meaning Which I have actually found the Sabbath. Malcolm Collins: Is, like, the key point before we get further in this of the entire Jesus story and what you’re supposed to take away from the New Testament is the the... Like, the line, I think, that encapsulates the the purpose of Jesus in reforming Judaism is the Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath. Yeah. because that line captures the point. It basically reframes our entire relationship with God. it is God gives us rules for our benefit. Simone Collins: Yeah. This produces human flourishing. This ain’t this ain’t gonna ruin you. It it doesn’t have to... If it feels bad, you’re probably doing it wrong. Speaker 4: Essentially, all of it. All of the the core sins that are discussed in the bible, are there because they are bad things to do. They are sins against yourself. They are things that make your own life worse, and they are God just giving you advice. Like, here’s the list. Okay? You know, don’t spend a lot of time thirsting after what other people have on Instagram. Be nice to your parents. They’re not gonna be here forever. You know, like, don’t... Basic stuff. Stuff that is just strictly beneficial to you as a human being. And Christianity, I think, when understood in the way that I understand it, is the understanding that all of these rules that can seem arbitrary or like you’re following some agreement for God to make God happy misunderstands everything. No. These were just advice to help you in your own life. Like, when somebody comes to us and they go, oh, do you think you need to follow the Sabbath to be right by God? I’m like, no. I think God at one point came down. I was like, hey. You should probably, like, make a concerted point to take one day off a week. And some people were like, no. F you. I don’t like all your extra rules. And it... And it’s like, okay. Sure. It... That’s not the key point in all of this, but I just was trying to help you out here, people. Malcolm Collins: This is why when when a lot of Christians are like, and that’s why we don’t need to follow any of the 10 commandments. It’s like, what if the 10 commandments so bad? Simone Collins: Yeah. How how is it so so hard to not kill people, to not covet things? Anyway, I wanna be clear, though. The the the most common depiction of Jesus, is of the good shepherd. So check him out. Oh, look at that. He’s wearing a ram on his Right. So this is the most common early depiction of Jesus as the good shepherd. Although he’s a really good shepherd because he’s wearing a whole ram on his on his shoulders. It’s just perching there. I think it’s really cute, actually. Kinda like a pirate. He’s got the the ram. but this this is a beardless, short haired youth carrying a a sheep. This is borrowed directly from classical cry... Cryophorus, that is to say, ram bearer figure, and probably not meant as a portrait of the historical Jesus at all. Like, it’s more symbolic. Malcolm Collins: Well, yeah, because that that would have been seen as, you know Less idolatrous. I I... Yeah. Idolatry by the early church. Simone Collins: Because we are talking about... I’m talking about... You don’t have to talk about... I’m gonna talk about that because I think it’s idolatrous what we’re doing anyway. No. Well, not me. Not me. Do you see me wearing crosses? Anyway, just wanna be clear. It it... Other early types of of art depicting Jesus, or referring to him refer to him visually as a miracle worker, sometimes holding a wand or as a philosopher teacher in a toga holding a scroll. And in the earliest images, he’s often a stocky, short haired, beardless figure in a short tunic who can only be identified by context. So there might be a lot of false positives in people being like, I think this is early art of Jesus because he’s not on a cross. And maybe that’s actually one of the reasons why... And this is my speculation here. Historians are not guessing this. Why Jesus on the cross became such a popular piece of art or maybe even why people started recognizing that and then assuming it was, like, the only way to depict him because, like Malcolm Collins: Because you would know it was definite. Otherwise, he’s Simone Collins: just your everyday guy. Like, he... Malcolm Collins: Because he was one of Simone Collins: the people. You know, he didn’t dress in a fancy way. He wasn’t trying to put on airs, and that can make it hard to visually distinguish someone who’s god. Right? Like, that’s kinda tough, you know, because you you wanna make them... Aside from, like, drawing a halo, I guess, which you could try to see. Malcolm Collins: Did. Well, I wonder when they started drawing a halo on him. I’m gonna ask. Simone Collins: Yeah. You can ask while I while I move forward. Right? So the the crucifixion is totally absent from Roman catacombs and sarcophagi, and the earliest surviving image of the the... As you say, the crucifixion is actually hostile. It’s the Alexomenos graffito scratched in Rome around the year 200 mocking a Christian by showing a donkey headed figure on a cross, with a little inscription basically amounting to Alexamenos worships his god or worships god. So they’re basically like, go worship your donkey god, Malcolm Collins: Alexamenos. Alexamenos. Alexamenos. Nerd. Simone Collins: Nerd. So the first Christian made depictions and not your weird scary witch stuff that you showed earlier on the bloodstone appear only in the early fifth century with the mascot ivory panel, which is currently visible in the British Museum. We probably walked by it and, like, didn’t think anything of it. It looks like, this. and here you see... Actually, Jesus doesn’t look like he’s suffering in this ivory panel. What you’re seeing is four men carved into ivory. one looks like he’s really... Okay. Maybe he’s hanging from a tree. I don’t Malcolm Collins: know if One looks like he’s hanging from a tree. Speaker 5: Yes. That’s Judas Iscariot. And below him, you can see a bag of coins that he dropped. Simone Collins: and then, you know, Jesus is... He he isn’t looking necessarily like he’s suffering. He’s sort of looking up and outward a little bit stoically, and then there are sort of people around him looking like they’re... I’m I’m not sure, really. It’s not very clear. You know? It’s it’s not the best art in the world, but they were doing what they could with what they had. Okay? And this was made around the year 04/20 to 04/30. That is way after. Of course, Christianity was was was swinging off. So just wanna be clear about that. That’s one of the earliest depictions of by... You know, a devout Christian of the the Uh-oh. The crucifixion. What? The halos? Malcolm Collins: Yeah. You know what they were originally used for? Uh-oh. As a symbol for pagan gods. Simone Collins: Duh. Uh-oh. No halos. No. No. No. No. Malcolm Collins: So the circle arrayed halos existed in holistic Roman and eastern art for gods, especially the Helios or soul. Oh, emperors also use them. Simone Collins: Oh my gosh. Get all the halos in art. Malcolm Collins: No. No. No. No. See it on Jesus until the fourth century. Simone Collins: Wow. Okay. Well, so just around the time when the cross. And so here’s another one of the first times that Jesus was depicted on a cross. This comes from a very, very large... Like, we’re talking, like, two story carved door. it’s it’s called the Santa Sabina in Rome. It was made circa 432, and this is the earliest public crucifixion image. And so do you have any guesses as to why people started depicting Jesus on a cross? Malcolm Collins: Well, I’m gonna note something first before we go further with this. It is interesting to me how the stuff within pop culture that people see as fake and pagan is actually not. And the stuff in popular culture that people think of as trad Christianity is actually fake and pagan. So examples here, which we have episodes on if you wanna go watch, the the idea that Christmas comes from a pagan holiday Simone Collins: People get so mad with us. Malcolm Collins: You’ve gotta you’ve gotta watch our episode on that. People got so mad at that episode, but it is Yes. I did. Just like evidence was overwhelming that it did not come downstream. They’ll say it came from the soul holiday, but, like, the soul holiday, happened on the same day, our first depictions of that aren’t until after our first depictions of Christianity coming to exist. People just assume because it was a pagan holiday, it came before Christianity, but we actually don’t see it until after Christianity. And it was first talked about by Christian communities who would have known the importance of that date. And then before that, people will try to convict it with, like, Saturnalia, but Saturnalia was on a completely different set of days. It was just, like, the same month. But, like, the holidays weren’t very similar. As you’ll see if you go into our episode on that, they... Does... It does not appear that, like, one came for the other. That... The the Easter people also think of as as pagan, and, I think we have an episode on that. And if we don’t, we should make an episode on that. So so you’ve got those things that are not pagan that everyone assumes are pagan. And then you’ve got things Note, it’s not that things like Eastern don’t draw from common non... Well, nonbiblical folk traditions, but they are folk traditions that arose in an already Christian community Simone Collins: Okay. Malcolm Collins: And don’t have traceable pagan roots to... Like, basically, there... It’s such a late phenomenon that there’s just no way it came from anything pagan, like the Easter bunny and stuff like that. But there there just wasn’t paganism still being practiced in these communities to the extent where people would still understand it from when these phenomenon emerged. Speaker 6: To put it another way, suppose a Christian holiday evolved around the VeggieTales cartoon. Now that’s not exactly a biblical thing, but it’s also not a pagan thing. And you could look and say, look at this vegetable holiday. There was this pagan vegetable holiday all the way back, like, four thousand years before. But it’s like, yeah. But the origin of this came from a Christian children’s cartoon. And they’re like, well, what makes it Christian? And I’m like, well, it was meant teach Christian themes in a Christian community. maybe maybe that’s a little strong. Maybe it’s like if if if you’re gonna push it even further, Bluey. Okay. Like, Bluey isn’t pagan. Okay? It’s just non Christian in a Christian dominated community. Malcolm Collins: But the things that are fake and gay, the things that are actually anti Christian or non Christian are things like the halo, things like Jesus on a cross, things like, well, that that does have a biblical origin, but for a long time is considered like black magic. Right? Yeah. or things like, Oh, the beard. Jesus with a beard. That was a sign of Simone Collins: Long beard. Malcolm Collins: Yeah. They used to depict... Roman and Greek gods was that, and so people started depicting Jesus was that to be like, look. He looks like a god. Simone Collins: Yeah. Like, I’m Malcolm Collins: trying to make him look... How do I make him look Simone Collins: 18% more authoritative? I know. Oh, man. That guy, Zeus, he looks real author... Like, every statue you see is of, like, the gods, and they look super beardy. So now we’ve got a Malcolm Collins: a crucified Zeus. Jesus would be incredibly confused if you showed him a picture of a a guy crucified with a a a big beard and a halo. He’s like, why is that great god? Simone Collins: Yeah. It seems... Well, yeah, especially Old Testament god, very, like, clear about I’m really not cool with you guys worshiping other... Like, I don’t... This this... One, idol worship bad. Two, I don’t like your other gods. And now I’m gonna actually argue that the reason why cross worship and cross in art, like Jesus on the cross in art became so popular, is functionally idol worship. Alright? Malcolm Collins: Oh, tell me. Simone Collins: Yeah. So scholars think that art of Jesus on the cross became popular because of this sort of legendary discovery of the true cross, the the the cross on which Jesus was crucified. And cavalry, aka But the... Basically, the place where Jesus was crucified becoming a pilgrimage site. Speaker 19: To explain this a bit more tightly, essentially, happened is when you have the creation of the first major pilgrimage site, almost like a religious Disneyland is what it was for its time period, is people would go there, and then they wanted a souvenir to bring back. And the souvenir options of, like, an anchor or a dove figurine or a fish figurine were just, one, not very evocative, and, two, not very tied to that specific site. And so what they began to use instead was either, individual crosses or what are called pilgrimage flasks, which were small bottles that we’ve even found, like, stamps and, like, things to see how they were mass produced in the region, Speaker 20: To be more specific, they were cheap mass produced engineers often flask or round flask shaped with a short neck and sometimes a loop so that they could be worn around their neck. Many were decorated or stepped with molded scenes. The crucifix or an empty jeweled cross being adorned was a very common one. However, there were other ones that were tied to the specific region. Speaker 21: These range from specific shrines or temples that were at Jerusalem during the period to more general stuff with a regional connection, like the empty tomb or the Magi. Speaker 20: Essentially, like, you know, you go to Disneyland and you can get the Mickey Mouse, which would be the cross, or you can get any of the various rides depicted on it. It just wouldn’t make sense to depict a universal sign of Christianity like the fish or the anchor or something like that. Now, obviously, this later became a universal sign of Christianity, but I’m talking about during the period Simone Collins: And I see pilgrimages to go see relics as classic idolatry. Let’s go find object and worship it. What? Malcolm Collins: Can we go back? Like... But this is I have to But they’ll say they’ll say, I’m not worshiping it. I just using it. Simone Collins: Helping me get closer to... No. No, guys. No. No. No. Stop. But I have to... Look. Remember, like, during this period, people didn’t have access. Like, there was very little reading. There wasn’t a printing press. They didn’t have access to the bible. They didn’t know at the time that Old Testament god was, like, very clear about this because no one was... I think I... I’m I’m gonna attribute it to ignorance. Now, however, we know better and shave on anyone who engages in this now. Anyway, so No. Malcolm Collins: But hold on, Simone. You’ve gotta listen. They’ll say it doesn’t count because I called it something else. No. It’s like, it’s not murder because I called it a silly tool. Stop. Stop. I I do love this that you just rename them as icons. And and and, again, it’s the idea that it’s about, oh, this object helps me get closer to the thing. Okay. that’s clearly what you’re not allowed to do. It’s not just a banning of other gods or icons of other gods. Otherwise, it would have been covered by the first commandment. The reason you have the clarifying second commandment that many denominations of Christianity actually rope into the first commandment to make it not so loud is because it’s saying, and not this as well given that we just established no other god. So when I talk about icons, I’m clearly not talking... Or when I talk about idols, I’m clearly not talking about gods. I’m talking about idols of even me. But, again, this is because we’re Protestant Max. So Simone Collins: As in we actually believe in reading the bible. We believe in following the actual rules instead of what a bureaucracy made up over hundreds of years. But let’s... So do you know about emperor Constantine’s mummy? Malcolm Collins: No. Tell me about it. Simone Collins: She was a famous travel influencer. Alright? She, like, super made religious pilgrimages the hot thing to do. She was the OG Instagram travel influencer before it was, you know... We we knew it was, you know, Instagrammammals or whatever they had back then, you know, when they were carving their stupid graffiti on stuff. So she... A a... Like like, per per the legend, Helena, mother of emperor Constantine, traveled to Jerusalem around the year 326 to 328, and then legendarily prompted by a dream or divine sign. She had a temple of Venus or Aphrodite built over, Golagotha, Speaker 7: Golgotha, if you’re wondering. Not Golgotha as I had originally thought. Simone Collins: the the cavalry, by Hadrian torn down. So she tore it down, and then excavations beneath it uncovered three crosses plus the Tittulus, the the plaque reading Jesus of Nazareth, king king of the Jews. The true cross was identified when a dying woman who touched it was miraculously healed. So somehow, she’s she’s gone on vacation to Jerusalem, takes a pilgrimage, tears down a temple built by Hadrian, and they find some morsels of of lumber as as was stated in Jesus Shaves by David Sedaris. And a woman touches a morsel of lumber and is is cured miraculously. And so they decide that that means that this this deaf... Oh, that plus the sign is definitely the true cross. Okay? And what historians actually say is that cross relics are being venerated in Jerusalem by the three forties already. Bishop Cyril Malcolm Collins: of Jerusalem By the way, I’m I’m gonna note because I’m asking AI this. I don’t think Romans just, like, left the crosses to rot on the hill next to a major city. Simone Collins: Oh, you’d think they’d recycled them. Malcolm Collins: I’m I’m pretty sure they were, like, reused for others. Simone Collins: Exactly. Exact... Oh, no. I would just recycle the morsels of lumber. But, anyway, so bishop Cyril of Jerusalem mentions them, that is to say, the morsels of lumber, in sermons from 351, but he never credits Helena with finding them. So I think they just start turning up, because this is kind of the... It’s chic at the time. Okay? And then the attribution to Helena first appears decades after she died in Ambrosa’s funeral oration for Theodysius in 395 and Galatias of Caesarena, whatever, church history around 390. So most scholars accept that Helena was not actually responsible for the discovery of these morsels of lumber and that the relics actually surfaced during Constantine’s church building on the site. So where did the wood go when these alleged pieces of the cross were discovered by someone, I don’t know, during construction By Malcolm Collins: by the way, for people who are wondering, because I I did need to do a sanity check on this. Yeah. There is no way this was the original cross. So for an understanding of how the the crucifixions were done, they they would take you off with the the horizontal beam. Okay. And they would reuse that horizontal beam for other crucifixions. Sure. Because, I mean, it’s... Simone Collins: You know, you have to, like, work hard to Malcolm Collins: Well, also, was valuable during Simone Collins: the year. Malcolm Collins: Right? Like, you wouldn’t just especially in Simone Collins: a developed area. Yeah. You have to, like, save trees and stuff. You can’t just go on. Malcolm Collins: So you wouldn’t have had, just three crucifixes happen to be there. You’d have a field of standing beams. Yeah. That that that would have been the way they they stayed normally. So if they just rotted over time, it would look like a standing beam. The horizontal beam was taken off when the person was taken off, which makes a lot of sense to me. because remember, Jesus had to carry his beam. Right? The the whole thing. And he wasn’t, I I think what this implies is he wasn’t carrying a full cross. He was carrying the horizontal beam, which also makes sense. Simone Collins: His mounting beam, we could call it. Malcolm Collins: How how silly would it be for them to put the whole cross back in the ground? Simone Collins: Well, this is... I mean, it’s the same with the ark too. Like, the ark has been stolen so many times or, like, it’s it’s been sort of lost and whatnot. Like, it Malcolm Collins: is almost certainly a meltdown. The point I’m making here. I’m just saying how logistically insane it would be Sure. For Jesus to carry and then... Because that would have to plant the cross, like, bottom of the cross Into the ground Which which would be a ton of work when you could just do that once and have a standing execution site. Simone Collins: For sure. Yeah. And, no, absolutely. I I agree. I mean, and it’s it’s not... So, theoretically, the lumber could have stayed around. Like, there is almost 300 year old lumber in our house. Right? Like, I’m trying to get more of it right now. I’m kinda worried about it. We’re... We gotta get on that. But, like, it it is a... Like, the wood could survive, but that it would be there, that there would be a placard. Like, what I really think is people are are... They’re see... They see an industry. There’s a market opportunity, and it’s just so tempting to be like, this was from the cross. Like, let’s... I will sell it to you for a small fee. And I think that just kind of started happening. But then... So it basically... Oh, sorry. Where... I want... I just wanna be clear about where these these pieces of wood still ended up, okay, at least where people say they ended up. So they they say that some of this alleged original lumber stayed in Jerusalem, and it was enshrined in a silver case in the Church Of The Holy Sepulchre that Constantine built over the site. And, part of it went to Constantine himself along with the nails, the alleged nails, because apparently, kept the nails separate. Like, I imagine they would reuse the nails too. We also know... Like, because we also have very old handmade nails in our house, and they’re extremely precious. No one would, like... Malcolm Collins: I think they would Yeah. Leave the nails there. Nails were worth quite Simone Collins: a I wish I had one sitting around. Like, they’re they’re really impressive, like handmade nails, and I don’t I don’t think they would have found them. But, anyways, the alleged nails went to Rome, and Helena reportedly brought fragments back to Rome as well along with the nails. And they were placed in her palace chapel, which is now the Basilica Of Santa Croce in in Jerusalem where they can still be seen as relics. And then even though this started happening and it became chic to go on pilgrimages to see the relics and engage in idolatry because you... I’m gonna say because you didn’t know better, Malcolm Collins: the point here being... One of one of the things I wanted to check is if the Bible gets any of this incorrect with common Roman practices. Yeah. And and, no, while modern translations say that he he was bearing his own cross, the the actual word here could easily mean he was just carrying the horizontal beam. Simone Collins: The mounting the mounting Yeah. Malcolm Collins: And and there’s no depiction of them, like, hammering it in or something like that. Yeah. So, yeah, this this all aligns. Simone Collins: Exactly. But... Wait. So, like, long story short, though, cross depictions became chic when what I’m gonna argue is a mixture of chic tourism and influencing, plus idol worship, plus rampant fraud of selling of relics that were all fake, which you you showed to be quite plausible, started to make people basically wanna be like, oh, like, commemorative. Like, I saw the cross, and all I got was this stupid cross art. You know, like, they they wanted to show off or that they they had seen the... A relic, the morsel of lumber. and despite this fact that that, you know, you start to see this art emerge at this time because of basically a tourism and fraud fad, the subject still stayed pretty uncommon until the sixth century. So, like, two hundred years ish later when then finally it spread, surprise surprise, via pilgrim flasks from the Holy Land. So, like, literally, souvenir tchotchkes from the fraud business industry. Okay? Malcolm Collins: That that is really not... We... I love that it goes from mockery to black magic to fraud. To... Yeah. Literally, like, you’re stupid. Simone Collins: I went to Cancun shirt. The the mystery spot bumper sticker. That is what this is. I’m I’m I’m so angry, but also some Byzantine art. And and it did not truly multiply in the West until the Carolingian era in the ninth century. So, like, it took forever. But the earliest populations of it were this this tourism scam fraud thing. And it’s... Oh my gosh. It’s just... It’s so sane. But, anyway, this early art, nevertheless, shows a living triumphant Christ with his eyes open. The dead suffering Christ only replaced it around the mid eleventh century. So it wasn’t until even later that we get into this, oh, well, let’s make him suffer. I’d love to see him not happy. You know? I’d love... It’s so messed up if you actually love Jesus. I’m I’m super not cool with it. Anyway, though, like you were saying, you personally think the cross looks pretty badass. Right? Malcolm Collins: Yes. I think the crusader cross looks pretty badass. Simone Collins: Yeah. You’re like, oh, and, you know, you are super not alone in this. Okay? So first off, the cross as a sign is definitely older than crucifixion crucifixion imagery because obvious... It’s one of the simplest things you could possibly do with shapes. Okay? Yeah. It’s not like, you know, we we was invented around this time for a crucifixion thing. The t shape was used as a seal by the second century, and the storogram, which is overlapping tau and rho, letters from, I think, the the Greek alphabet, right, appears inside the New Testament papyri, like p 66 around 2200, which makes it Christianity’s early visual reference to the crucifixion. Because I never seen... I guess I had seen this diagram. Have you seen this before? So it looks like a p plus a t. A capital p plus a t. It’s it’s not... This ain’t rocket science. Speaker 8: No. Here, what I find fascinating is it turns out that this symbol was actually used before Christians were around as, a monetary sign on coins. Think of it almost like the dollar sign derivative of the s. Malcolm Collins: That’s the earliest depiction? Simone Collins: Yeah. And this this would show up in papyri, New Testament papyri like p 66. And... But that was still around the year 200. Okay. So still, the dominant pre Constantinian symbols were the fish, the anchor, and the dove, and they were used very discreetly by a persecuted minority. Speaker 15: One of the very important thing about, like, the fish sign and the dove and all that is that it was very difficult, these early signs, to turn into an icon that you attempted to worship as an intermediary for god in the same way that later symbols were very easy to do that with. Simone Collins: So keep in mind also, right, we aren’t gonna be super, like, flashy with, like Malcolm Collins: Well, early Christians loved getting martyred. Simone Collins: Okay. The martyrs were flashy, but everyone else was like, I’m just gonna draw a dove. Malcolm Collins: By by the way, I don’t mean that, as a joke. I I mean that You mean seriously? There was, like, a crisis when they, took over power in Rome, and they stopped murdering Christians because they didn’t know what to do to suffer enough. Oh, yeah. Because they they became this... I mean, Jesus was murdered. Right? So, like, people were like, martyrdom is awesome. Yeah. And that’s how the monastic movement started. It’s people were like, well, Simone Collins: What else can I do? Malcolm Collins: Go out and live in the desert and try to make my life harder, and that can be kind of like martyrdom. Yeah. And we have an episode where we talk about how martyrdom became so popular. But, like, basically, the Romans really up how they martyred people. They would... Like, we have one account of it. and when I say they... Of how they martyred people, they’d be taking a guy to the Colosseum, and they’d have, like, two giant guards with him, but they’d let him go on, like, a tour speaking. Simone Collins: So, like, say you’re arrested somewhere outside Rome for being a Christian. Well, what would happen is that you would be taken to Rome for your for your coliseum based killing where the lions would eat you or whatever. But then on your way, as you were escorted back for your for your execution, the the... They would let you stop and give sort of talks. And I think maybe the the Roman guards or or the law enforcement were like, yeah. This will be a scared straight kind of program. Right? But then the Christian thought is like, my departure tour. You know? Like, they’re going on tour. Malcolm Collins: No. And they would get huge crowds at this point. Simone Collins: And, of course, like, everyone wants to turn out to see the guy who’s about to get killed. Right? Like, he’s gonna be beaten by lions. Let’s see what he has to say. Malcolm Collins: They’re like, oh, he must really believe this stuff. He’s really into... And then he’s surrounded by these two figures that show him authority. Like, these two Simone Collins: I know. He’s flanked by his, what do they call them? What do the red pillars call them? Your wingman? Your Wingman? Yeah. Yeah. It’s it’s very red pill dynamic. Yeah. He was he was so hot. I’m sure. I’m sure they they I guess, Malcolm Collins: but, like, they couldn’t have done anything dumber to to... If you understood, like, the message of Christianity. Simone Collins: Right? Malcolm Collins: Like, it also really works with the message of Christianity. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You know? That’d great. And that was that was... And, you know, early Christians thought, keep in mind, life really sucked in Roman society. Simone Collins: It did. Malcolm Collins: It did. Like, getting to be famous and go out and then, like, immediate automatic heaven because martyrdom is what they put back then. Yeah. Simone Collins: Yeah. Yeah. So that was a thing. Right? So they had to be very... But but the ones who weren’t... Because look. Not everyone wants to be eaten by lions or whatever. And so many people were subtle about it, and so they used the imagery, most commonly, again, of the the the anchor, the fish, or the dove. Alright? And those are those are extremely... That’s not idolatrous. That’s not reading idolatrous to me. That is not reading... I wish we could bring that back. Fish anchored up. I mean, we... I I don’t actually... Remember how people used to put those fish magnets on their cars? Malcolm Collins: No. The the the fish was really... Is is really common among Protestants. Simone Collins: What happened to the fish? I have not seen a fish on a car forever. Malcolm Collins: I haven’t seen... I think it’s what happened to Christians. You were the one who told me that over fifty percent of Americans no longer believe in a virgin birth. Simone Collins: Yeah. Recent stat. Recent stat. Fresh off the presses. But, yeah, it’s a... Yeah. It... Wow. Because I remember seeing those all the time in the San Francisco Bay Area as a kid, which is saying a lot because that is a godless place. So... Wow. That’s that’s impressive. Anyway, so the turning point, visually speaking here, was Constantine because he made it okay, as you’re saying, to... You know, it was legal to be Christian suddenly. And people had the the the crisis of martyrdom, but they also had this, I guess, renaissance of of visual signaling freedom. Okay? But, basically, after Constantine had this vision before the battle of Milvian Bridge in 03/12, he adopted the Cairo monogram on his army’s shields as... And standards as his public endorsement. And this changed the cross’s connotation from a slave’s execution device to a revered emblem Speaker 9: Okay. Simone is a little misleading or confused in the way she describes things here, it’s easy to understand why. Remember how earlier we were talking about the chiro symbol and it looked a lot like a modern cross, and you could be like, oh, yes. This came or was a progenitor of the idea of the modern cross. The chairo that Constantine used looked nothing like that. I have an image on screen here. It looks more like an x with a p through it. you might be able to get a Saint Andrew’s cross from it, but, like, obviously, that is not what this was connected to. What this actually is or a better way to understand it is similar to a logo that Simone and I used that has our initials superimposed on top of each other in an artistic fashion, which I have next to it here. It was the chai, which comes from the of Christos, and the row, which comes from the of Christos. it’s more like superimposed initials of the key sounds of the name Christ in a way to represent him without using a cross. Like, it’s very explicitly avoiding using a cross. Simone Collins: . So let me show you By by the Malcolm Collins: way, just... As long as we’re debunking rumors here. The idea that the fish was a secret sign of Christianity where one person would do one part of the fish, and then they were a Christian, they would complete the fish, That has no historic evidence to it. That was an idea that was popularized in the nineteenth or twentieth centuries. That it was a discrete sign of early Christianity is absolutely true. We see it as early as, like, the third and the second century. Okay. But that it was, like, this secret ritual or something like that. No. Simone Collins: Okay. So this is a missorium. Do you know what a missorium is? I’d not I’d not heard of one before. Malcolm Collins: No idea. Simone Collins: What we are looking at here is a a large, heavily decorated ceremonial silver plate that would be given by a late Roman or Byzantine emperor to a high ranking civil or military official to mark an important anniversary. But the important thing about this particular missorium is that it depicts emperor Constantine the great’s son, Constantinius the second, accompanied by a guardsman with the chiro depicted on his shield. So to your point about... You can see it. It’s over here. It’s to the to the left. Yeah. You see the little... The, like, p right there? Malcolm Collins: Yep. Simone Collins: He thinks it’s badass like you do, and you wanna go into battle with that thing on your shield, and he made it cool. Okay? Malcolm Collins: Well, Kulzetin famously put something. I forgot what sign it was on on his shields and won the battle. Right? Simone Collins: Yeah. Though that’s what... That is what I’m talking about. Malcolm Collins: That’s Oh, that’s what he put on the shields? Okay. Simone Collins: Yeah. Because he had this vision before a battle. And so he he sort of rebranded the cross from we use this to shame people and execute them and do terrible things to them to, like, this is a point of pride. This is an affiliation with something that... It was almost like a... What do they call that where you take something where they, like, they call you a bad name and then you you own the name, you appropriate it? You... Malcolm Collins: Yeah. I don’t know. Appropriation. Simone Collins: With the n word and the f word where they’re like, well, I’m gonna use it now because Reappropriation, I think. Okay. He reappropriated the cross on behalf of Christians even though he was a Roman and... I don’t know. It’s... It seems Malcolm Collins: And he didn’t he didn’t Long but Christianize, like, quickly after this either. He he converted a fit... Like, the baptism... When we we... So it was often that if you were an emperor back then or, like, a a powerful Christian, you would get baptized later. So it doesn’t necessarily mean he wasn’t fully Christian during this part of his life. The reason they would get baptized later is they thought baptism wiped away your sins. Simone Collins: And so you wanna get it, like You accumulate more sins. Malcolm Collins: Yeah. You accumulate more sins. Simone Collins: You take the shower right before you go Malcolm Collins: But when he forced the council of Nicene or Nicene, that... He was still unbaptized. Right? Like, he was still... And, you know, is sort of forcing the wording on that and then excommunicating the people. But I think literally banishing them, the ones who wouldn’t agree with him, I think, shows, like, the degree of... I mean, he really shaped Christianity during that period. And I think in a way... Yeah. Obviously, he helped Christianity spread, which was fantastic, but I think he’s sort of the root of the institutional rot within Christianity and the idea that, like... Because he he sort of bureaucratized it. Right? Like, he used it as his shadow bureaucracy to run the state, which was good. I mean, he he, like a Chad, got rid of the Pretorian Guard. Simone Collins: Thank goodness. Because they did a lot more backstabbing than they... I mean, maybe they helped for the most part. I I don’t know. But... Yeah. Malcolm Collins: No. No. They were... They did not help for the most part. They were tough. Simone Collins: Wow. Yeah. Good on him. Look. He... In the... In general, I I think he good. Malcolm Collins: But Yeah. No. We’re gonna name one of Simone Collins: our boys after him, probably. Yeah. I like Constantine. I like Constantine, but... Oh, Constantine for a girl. Come on. He’s pretty good. Kryptea. Malcolm Collins: Damn it. You’re not gonna get away from Kryptea. It is the one name I want more than any name for one of our kids. Well It is the coolest fucking name. How can I get out Simone Collins: of this? Great. Great. Anyway, basically... Okay. So he made it cool. He reappropriated it. However, the the plain Latin cross only became preeminent as this, like, Christian symbol in the late fourth century. So it it it, again, was very late. I think it’s a tourism scam thing. It it wasn’t really what early Christians wanted to do or meant to do. And and, again, this is, like, by very new Christians who are kind of getting on it as a fad in my opinion. But that’s just my opinion. Also, just a little bit touching on the the whole beard beard gate, with Jesus. Right? The the bearded long haired type first appears around 300 in the late third century, early fourth century, and the Catacomb Of Comodilla Comodilla holds what is often called the first known bearded Christ of the fourth century. Behold, I I present to you first beard, Daje Begg, which is how I labeled this. He he looks sad. He doesn’t look like he likes his beard, in my opinion. But, again, that is that is behold the first bearded Christ. Art historians trace the model to imperial imagery. Malcolm Collins: The Yeah. Because they’re also using the halo that would have been a sign of a god. Simone Collins: Exactly. They’re just like, how if I make him look more like an emperor? And above all, like, Jupiter or Zeus. Yeah. With with Serapis and Asclepius as related sources as a way of showing Christ as a cosmic ruler. So this is just, like, Zeus, but call him Jesus. That is what we’re looking at here, which is so crazy that this is the Jesus that everyone pictures and, like, heard... Like, if someone’s like, picture Jesus. You know, like, they’ve gone to your head. You know, picture Jesus. This is what’s gonna show up in your head. Right? The bearded Jesus. Well, I mean, I would probably picture Mormon Jesus. I don’t know why. It’s it’s so iconic. But Malcolm Collins: Oh, this is very interesting. Yeah. So Constantine’s mom it does not look like she she deceived people. So Simone Collins: You think she... No. From what I could tell historians, like, she didn’t No. Malcolm Collins: She never claimed to have found a cross. Simone Collins: Oh. That was Oh, people made it up. Malcolm Collins: That was made up later. This... That was made up about sixty to seventy years after her visit. Simone Collins: Okay. So she was a posthumous travel influencer Yes. Malcolm Collins: So so the... Her visit, what they said, the guy who who wrote about it said that when she demolished the Simone Collins: The temple. Malcolm Collins: Of Venus And then excavated it, what she found was a tomb, which, I mean, of course, there were tombs under ancient temples. Simone Collins: Yeah. You couldn’t, like, do anything without coming across But Malcolm Collins: she thought because she had a vision that it was real, like Christ’s tomb. And, yeah, the Bordeaux pilgrim around 333 visits also does not mention... Yes. So the Bordeaux pilgrim also does not mention any crosses at the location. Simone Collins: So it’s a bunch of charlatans trying to sell people cross morsels for churches and then also cross flasks as souvenirs for their tourism. Yeah. Malcolm Collins: A a a Jerusalem around 350 refers to pieces of crosses existing and being shown to pilgrims, but he does not credit Helena with finding them. Simone Collins: Oh, there you go. Yeah. So that’s... That is crazy. So, anyway The Malcolm Collins: the the story is just a fraudulent story. Right? Simone Collins: Fraudulent story. Malcolm Collins: That’s what that’s what... Even by, like, actual lore of the period, a fraudulent story. Simone Collins: Yeah. anyway, back to bearded Jesus. The the the Zeus Jesus depictions became popular around 300, but they weren’t the only way Jesus was depicted. They they still coexisted with the more clean shaven, youthful, beardless, short haired Jesus. Like, they they still showed him youthful and beardless, and the Ravenna mosaics of Saint Apollner Nuovo circa 05/20 show him beardless. So even, like, way, way later, he’s... He shows up as sort of the OG depiction, which is more accurate. The bearded image only became standard in Eastern... In the Eastern church by the sixth century. While in the West, clean shaven Christs remained common until the twelfth century. And then for whatever reason, and it sort of becomes a little bit less clear after that, people just adopted. Maybe it was because... Also, keep in mind that after the fall of Rome, like, seriously fall of Rome, and and you entered into the the the Middle Ages, because now I’m listening to a bunch of lectures in the Middle Ages, there was a ton of... This was, like, the first, obviously, period of obsession with the height of the Roman Empire because that was like, remember when we had plumbing? That was so cool. Like, they really had it figured out, and so everyone was fangirling about Romans. And so they would hold Roman art standards and Greek art standards as a sort of a higher aesthetic standard. So it doesn’t surprise me that more Zeus like depictions of Jesus would be popular because the more chic thing would be to kind of go after that style. Just how in, like, the early 18 hundreds, the neoclassical style was seen as, like, the sophisticated sophisticated way way to to do do things. Things. Yeah. Once again, we became obsessed with Rome. And so I think that’s more why after that point, Jesus became depicted in a more, we’ll say, Roman pagan style. And then sort of after that, because that was such a... That was when Western art started to become... You know, that’s when it... That that was, like, the the proto Renaissance. And then the Renaissance set the standard for everything else. So then it just sort of snowballs after that. And then now now we can’t get away from it. Like, could you imagine if someone tried to reintroduce a short haired, either, like, short bearded or beardless Jesus? Like, people would riot. Malcolm Collins: You can’t I mean, I’m open to reintroducing it. I think that if you depict him, you should depict him as accurately as you can. Right? Like, I Yeah. Simone Collins: But... No. Like, here’s my thing, though. I I think that that is a a fool’s errand. Because if you really wanna do, quote, unquote, the right thing, you need to go as far away from idol worship as possible. And I think if you need symbolism and you wanna show your affiliation and pride, you should show a fish or a dove or an anchor because you’re not gonna mistakenly start to worship those things. Or a pragmatisgier. Or a pragmatist gear for techno puritans. Look. That’s what you put on the on the, like, techno puritan nun style and pre style clothing in your fan art Yeah. Malcolm Collins: And I think it looks just as cool as a crusader cross. I I I I think it can. Yeah. And I and I like that it it it contains meaning behind, like, the the mechanistic nature behind reality. Simone Collins: And time and deterministic universes. Yes. Malcolm Collins: And this is a human machine. Control, like, a settings menu or something like that. Like, you control who you are. Yeah. That’s why I I I think it works on a a lot of levels without risking, the the negatives of, the cross, Simone Collins: which is just, like, way Malcolm Collins: too easy to start trying to worship through. Speaker 18: And same as... Which I think are all equally good symbols, the dove, the fish, and the anchor, it’s a lot harder to accidentally end up Iconizing it and using it as an intermediary for worship instead of just using it as a symbol For identification. Simone Collins: Well, the... That... I... First, I think it’s crazy, again, to focus on that aspect of his life at all. I mean, well, I... Okay. The sacrifice is very meaningful, but, like, to try to visually depict what clearly was a point of immense suffering for Jesus as is documented. Malcolm Collins: Like Again, my lord my lord, why have you forsaken me? Like, people are like, oh, he was just quoting at the time. And I’m like, I think he was quoting, but also in a lot of pain. Simone Collins: Yeah. I don’t I don’t think... Yeah. God didn’t, like, poof. You’re not feeling it. It’s just... Let’s not do a whole, oh, the the lobster doesn’t feel anything when you put it in the boiling water. So it’s fine. No. It’s really not. and it just... Yeah. It really... It’s, it bothers me in the same way that, like, people wanting to watch public executions and gawk at it bothers me. It’s... I think it’s Malcolm Collins: I’m I’m okay with public executions. You you know, the the Catholic church has been throwing a big fit about The US doing a public execution. And it’s Simone Collins: like is crazy to me because they were, like, the public execution people. Come on. Malcolm Collins: The public executions are are us is the Catholic church historically. Simone Collins: For real. Malcolm Collins: Yeah. And now they’re like, life is sacred. And I go, well, the the popes before you didn’t seem to think so. Simone Collins: Right. Yes. Very true. Very true. But I... Yeah. I... There there is... We, for example, are against forms of worship that hijack other things in your body to make you feel like you are having a religious experience when you’re not, like twirling in circles, like dancing. I actually... Malcolm, I haven’t talked with you about this, but I’m even getting uncomfortable with music because I know how music can give you really powerful feelings. And I think that using it in a religious setting can make you feel like you’re having a religious moment when you’re not because you’re just... Yeah. Malcolm Collins: I I I I will condone this. I I I mean, we do In the bible, we do see people singing, the lord’s praises. I think it’s good. Think see people. Think Simone Collins: and dancing. Music and dancing are fine, but don’t do it to think you’re closer to god. Do it to celebrate god. So there... Those are different things. Right? Singing the praises of god and dancing for god and showing that joy, I think, is good. So I think the the the Malcolm Collins: I think a good a good a good example of this is the difference between the way that, like, Orthodox Jews party. Yeah. I don’t if you’ve seen this, but it’s like you can very much tell from the way that they’re doing their weird Orthodox Jew party. They they don’t... I mean, maybe they do. But but my sort of read of it is it doesn’t feel like they’re doing it they’re doing it to praise life and to praise God. Simone Collins: Celebrating. They’re celebrating. Malcolm Collins: They’re not way of getting closer. Whereas if you go to, like, a Pentecostal Christian, like, a charismatic Christian church That’s where I think it’s... It really Simone Collins: draws lot. It’s in your Sunday worship service in place of seriously thinking about how to bring your life in greater alignment with god’s plan, like... Yeah. But... So, anyway, I disagree with the churches that are like, no music, no dancing because I think that misses the point. And, again, as you pointed out, the... We are we are encouraged to do that, to celebrate the greatness of God and his... All his creation, etcetera. But, yeah, the idea of doing that. But, anyway, I think that Jesus on the cross does something similar and that it is a... It... To see someone in in the midst of being tortured and killed can make you feel a lot of things. And I think that aside from the idolatry, that it kind of pulls some of those tricks in some instances and has been effective in that way in drawing attention as well. Like, when you see someone being tortured and killed, you’re like, what is that? Oh my gosh. And I don’t like that. I I I I think that that is I really... I think this Malcolm Collins: fits well with the broader techno puritan relationship with god that wouldn’t fit with a lot of other Christians where we believe Jesus was the Jewish messiah because of logic. And we would see anything that drew us to belief in God or Jesus that it is not logic is bad from our perspective. Right? Like, if we are drawn to it because of feels, because of, you know, whatever is masturbated through watching somebody suffer, and then you’re like, oh, like, that that creates this. Yeah. I can see why you’re like, that’s not a true faith. That’s a that’s a manipulated faith. It’s... That’s tainted by the... From our perspective, almost like dark ritual, that you did to obtain it Which is, you know, watching torture porn. Simone Collins: Yeah. Super messed up. So whole thing Speaker 10: If you’re wondering why, it’s because all of those same emotions can be derived from something else. You know, whether it’s any different faith, like, consider Muslims or Buddhists or whatever, they’ll describe ecstatic religious experiences that will sound very similar to Pentecostal ecstatic religious experiences. The fact that the very same emotions and drives can be used to pull you in the wrong direction is why we don’t trust them when they pull you in the right direction. Speaker 11: Because of the fact that you are feeling them is not an indication that the directionality in which they are pulling you is correct. Only the logic you apply to know whether that direction is correct is... It tells you whether that direction is correct. And we know from the bible in number of places, we’ll talk about this in prayer, that it is possible for demons to convince you that they are the word of angels or something like this. In fact, even Satan apparently regularly likes dressing up as this big bright angel, very, very bright he’s very into, and he uses that to deceive people. so this idea that just because you feel something very strongly means it’s true is something that I would advise guarding against. Speaker 12: Sorry. Just for lines here, lest you doubt me. the big one here is Corinthians eleven fourteen, and no wonder for Satan himself masquerades as an angel of light. Then you have Galatians one eight. Even in an angel from heaven preached a different gospel, it should be rejected. Appearance or claimed angelic origin is not enough. Then you have John four one. Dear friends, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God because many false prophets have gone into the world. Then you have Matthew twenty four twenty four. False messiah and false prophets will perform great signs and wonders to deceive, if possible, even the elect. Then you have, Deuteronomy thirteen one through three. Even if a prophet or dreamer gives a sign or wonder that comes true but then leads people to follow other gods, do not listen. The test of loyalty is from the true god, not the impressiveness of the experience. I know here you’re being very clear. It’s not the impressiveness of the experience. Okay? It’s whether or not it comes from the true god. And how do you determine if it’s the true god, if not from the impressiveness of the experience? From your logic. and this has happened to people in the past. In Kings 22, we know of the 400 prophets who were deceived by a lying spirit. King Ahab consults 400 prophets, and they all unanimously tell him he will succeed in battle. They even perform a kind of prophetic drama with iron horns. Only one true prophet, Micaiah, says the opposite. Micaiah then reveals what’s really going on in the spiritual realm. A spirit volunteered to be a lying spirit in the mouths of all those prophets. The whole group was deceived and deceiving others while speaking with great confidence and apparent spiritual authority. So, like, yeah, you you can, if you believe the bible, be tricked by this stuff. Speaker 13: And for those who are like, you guys approach this all too logically and too coldly and too whatever. And it’s like, that’s the only thing that can spiritually fortify you if spirits have access to the same level of ability to get you excited, get you happy, make you feel certain, make you feel that someone is talking to you, make you feel the spirit of light is talking to you. if if they have access to all of that to deceive you, the only counter you have to it is logic. And thank god that god gave us that logic. Simone Collins: ... Like, I’m I’m I’m glad we had this conversation because this is one of those things that from childhood, maybe from the very first time I saw a depiction of Jesus on the cross, I felt deep inside of me that this is wrong. And I... It’s very... I’m very smug about Well, I I think the Malcolm Collins: the reason why... Because Simone was the one who came at this, and she’s the one who’s always felt this more than I am. Yeah. And the thing that edifies for me your intuition about this being a bad thing, and this is the way we think that God speaks to Simone Collins: us. Scam? Malcolm Collins: no. It’s it’s the way it was used originally. Right? Like, if I had looked into the historical record and found this from day one and found that it was not, like, a tainted thing. But if it’s... In every way, it could have been twisted and wrong Twisted and wrong, then all I can, like, my takeaway is just, that’s that’s bad. Simone Collins: Yeah. This is the first depiction is mocking Christianity. Malcolm Collins: And then the depiction is used for black magic To siphon power from Christ. Horrific. Then the depiction is used as part of, like, a a... I mean, I guess you can say the Constantine on the shields, but that’s not even, like, a traditional cross. And then the depiction is used on... You know, popularized because of a scam. I think that that’s god because I didn’t know I would find all of that when I went into the history of it. And when I found all of that, that’s, like, for me, when I’m like, okay. God’s saying you guys are right in saying that you you shouldn’t be doing this. Because the bible doesn’t doesn’t... Because I don’t think anyone when the bible was written would have expected the cross to become a sign that people were showing around. Simone Collins: Because, I mean, look, most of the cool stories of the bible, again, like, back to the early art of Jesus are of Jesus healing, Jesus helping, Jesus teaching, Jesus questioning the bad bureaucratic practices as... Of people who’ve who’ve strayed from the true faith, from from actually following the the law. Malcolm Collins: A more meaningful thing even than the idea of Christ suffering for the the... You know, Christ suffering for our sins. I think a a more, to me, powerful is Christ just doing all of those good things. Going out there healing people, going out there teaching people. Simone Collins: Being the good shepherd. Malcolm Collins: And in Christ’s trial, that’s what he focused on. If if that he suffered and was was punished for trying to help people. And in his trial Simone Collins: things he did. Malcolm Collins: Yeah. When he... He was like, what what could you say that I did that was bad? I was, like, just teaching people and helping people. Like, where where is... I like, where’s all the bad stuff? He’s highlighting the hypocrisy of what’s about to happen, and I think that that’s where he drew attention to as well. Simone Collins: Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yeah. I just... Yeah. This has been very... I’ve... Cathartic. Thank you. Cathartic? Malcolm Collins: I know we got we got new techno puritan practices. Isn’t that wonderful? Yeah. Simone Collins: Well... Yeah. Yeah. I just... Yeah. I’ve Malcolm Collins: I mean, one of the things that you always see at techno puritan over and over and over again, and it’s something that, like, people will never pull us back from, is just, like, very strong resistance to idolatry. Like, I I just I think But it’s Simone Collins: the 10 commandments. Is this so hard? Like, if if there is one part of the bible that anyone’s gonna read Malcolm Collins: Well, yeah. But it’s not just that. I mean, I think it’s fast. Look. You you can you can argue that, well, it’s it’s from the bible. But I also think to just, like, the functional outcome of it. Right? Like Simone Collins: No. Sure. Sure. Sure. It it doesn’t lead in a good direction. Oh, a little aside, we’re watching Indiana Jones with the kids, the original. Right? What is it called? Raiders of the Lost Ark. Yeah. Raiders of the Lost Ark. And we were trying to explain the arc to them, like, why it mattered, you know, aside from the fact Malcolm Collins: that they’re cool. So funny. And Torsten goes, the Nazis have it. Are they gonna learn what it says inside? And and I was like, no. Like, everybody knows what it says inside. And he’s like, well, then do they, like, use that information? And I was like, remarkably, a bunch of... Even Christians, like, just don’t. They’re like, Christ fulfilling. It doesn’t matter anymore. Simone Collins: Yeah. I was like, actually, if they did use that information, they would become too powerful toasty. Malcolm Collins: Yeah. They they become too powerful. He’s like, uh-oh. The Nazis are gonna learn the 10 commandments. Yeah. It’s a... That... That’s... It’s been fun to watch that with the kids. Simone Collins: Very fun. Malcolm Collins: And they’re like, oh, no. Oh, no. How are they... Are the Nazis gonna figure it out? Yeah. Are the bad guys gonna learn the 10 commandments and become extremely powerful? Simone Collins: That’s the thing, though, is is the 10 commandments are extremely powerful, and I hold that if, like, you... If there’s a TLDR, that’s it. Malcolm Collins: Episode we’ll do on this, and I think it can be the one where I go more into Sabbath stuff, is the 10 commandments are awesome. Yeah. Because I I do actually think that they’re really, really clever. I know. But, like, so many, Simone Collins: I guess, you’ll say boomer conservatives are gonna Malcolm Collins: be like, well, duh. That’s why we wanted to put them in the walls in schools, and everyone had an aneurysm about it and couldn’t Well, I think that what’s undersold about what makes them so clever Is god could have put, you know, or let’s say Moses was a... Secretly chiseled them or whatever. Okay. Right? That’s, like, that’s an effing. Like, if if we say that Moses did it Okay That’s a, like, god tier play on Moses’ part for I only get 10 rules, and I have to make civilization work on these 10 rules. Like, they have to lead to a good civilization. And instead of putting in, like, a bunch of legal stuff or something like this, a large number of the rules are, like, don’t covet things your neighbor has. Yeah. Or, you know, honor your mother and father, which are just, like, rules about living a good life. Right? Like... And he puts in nothing like worship me. Like, pay attention to me. I’m number one. Right? Which, again, makes me think he probably didn’t do it himself. Or you have to be... You have to follow the state. You have to do what the state tells you to. You know, all the things you would expect if a human had put this together. But it’s full of, like, the best self improvement advice along with the minimum set of rules you need for a functional society. Simone Collins: Yeah. It’s perfect. Malcolm Collins: Which is pretty cool. Simone Collins: Well, we must prepare for the Sabbath. Speaking of Malcolm Collins: Love you. Simone Collins: Off you go. Love you. Is it gonna entertain me? Oh, I’ve... I know, like, this morning, you’re like, I can’t white knuckle it. I need to, you know, just have AI solve problems with homeschooling. But, like, the process of vibe coding around homeschooling problems while homeschooling is... That’s, like, more than white knuckling. That’s, like, bloody knuckling it. If that is... I don’t know what what you think is going on here, but Malcolm Collins: the kids how I solve every problem in my life now, Simone. To Simone Collins: bloody knuckle everything? Malcolm Collins: I do it. To it with Well, vibe coding a solution to it. Simone Collins: Yeah. Well, kids are brutal beta testers. Oh, do I have... I do. Malcolm Collins: We’ll we’ll have a really robust product in the end. Speaker 14: She’s talking about our children’s education, Android operating system, Mudpuppy dot a I backslash OS, which you can flash an Android with and just give it to your kids and, I guess, explore it for yourself. Speaker 17: Octavia and I got stuck by this whole travel thing. So we’re we’re stuck at a random airport, and I was like, you know what? If we’re stuck here for a few days, I’ll make the best of it. Speaker 16: Explain to everyone why daddy’s freezing right now and what just happened? So you went in the pool. What... You went right... You were right there. Yeah. I was right there enjoying myself. And then literally thirty seconds after entering, what did you do? I was just drowning. I was I was doing all the safety moves. I was like You were not doing any safety moves. You were just drowning. Did you see me do it? You did not. You was you was flat. It sounded like a. We’re gonna get you some lessons. Don’t worry. Right.