← technopuritan.com · a working analysis of the Techno-Puritan corpus · companions: Proper Worship Practices · The Assembly Concordance · The Seventh Day · Meat and Drink · Not by Command · Four Tellings · This Generation · The World to Come · Eshet Chayil · All Hallows' Even · Risking Life for Thrills · The Genesis Ledger · The New Religion Census
What is prayer for, in this tradition, and what should you expect from it? The proposal under test: prayer is a time set apart from ordinary thinking to quietly consider your life choices, the world, what you are grateful for and what other people are carrying. It is not a time to try to talk to God expecting a voice to answer and guide you, because that is dangerous. This page checks that proposal against the Techno-Puritan corpus and against the Bible itself. The short answer: the corpus backs it plainly, and in places more sharply than the proposal does. The Bible backs the quiet, the privacy, the few words, the thanks and the prayers for others. One correction: in the text, prayer is still addressed ("Our Father", "Abba"), not only thought to oneself. What the tradition removes is the expectation of a reply, not the address.
The corpus says three things about prayer in so many words. First, God does not answer you by voice: "Just go personally pray on it and God will tell you the right answer, where I don't think that that's how God communicates with people" (TP 8.0), and "personal revelation and praying directly to God and then God tells you, but that's not right" (TP 5.0). Second, the voice people do hear is their own wishes wearing God's name, and that is idolatry: "When humans attempt to model God they create the way they wish He existed rather than how He does, which leads to sinful self-indulgence" (TP 8.0). Third, the useful address is forward: "when we tell our children to pray to supernatural agents we tell them to pray to their distant descendants," because modelling what they would ask of us comes "closer to God's will than attempting to directly model the will of God" (TP 8.0). Add the tracts' rejection of trance, chanting and emptying the mind (TP 6.0, TP 7.0) and the scripture on secrecy and few words, and what is left is the proposal: quiet, private, deliberate thought, addressed upward or forward, with no answer expected and a decision at the end.
Everything the captured corpus says on prayer that bears on the question, quoted from the text. The corpus has nothing on gratitude in prayer or praying for other people; those two parts of the proposal stand on scripture alone (Exhibit B) and are a gap for a future tract.
"Just go personally pray on it and God will tell you the right answer, where I don't think that that's how God communicates with people… I know people who have had those profound experiences with communicating with God, and the things that they tell me God has communicated to them definitely were demonic, definitely were not from God."Malcolm Collins, Tract 4, TP 8.0. Simone, same passage: "to put it in layman's terms, were the things that they wanted to hear."
"A lot of people are going to turn to personal revelation and praying directly to God and then God tells you, but that's not right."Simone Collins, Tract 6, TP 5.0
"When humans attempt to model God they create the way they wish He existed rather than how He does, which leads to sinful self-indulgence. This reminds me of a woman we know who told us she always listened to her husband except when God told her otherwise… how very convenient that God had a penchant for her preferred indulgences."Tract 4, TP 8.0 (written text and podcast)
"This is always a problem I see when people say, you know, I talk to God, because then that thing that they're talking to, the way they wish God was, can affirm indulgences."Tract 4 podcast, TP 8.0
"Man as he exists now can not have a relationship with God… God is so great that he does not deign to have personal relations with us human atoms that are called men. Those who desire to worship their Creator must worship him through mankind."Tract 4, TP 8.0, quoting Winwood Reade
"When they pray and ask God what they should believe, He tells them to be Muslim."TPG 26.4: the Christian who says God confirms his choice in prayer has an argument every Muslim can use; and the many mutually exclusive answers people receive are "direct evidence for a God that is lying to at least one group", if you treat them as communication at all.
Practices "such as chanting, fasting, sleep deprivation, and hallucinogenic use, while seemingly profound, are often used by malevolent actors to manipulate and control followers… true closeness to God is achieved through logic, pragmatism, and efficacious action, not the pursuit of altered mental states."Tract 5 summary, TP 6.0
"Pushing all of this out of yourself is not where God comes in. God comes in through your industry, through achieving things that actually matter."Tract 5 podcast, TP 7.0, on John of the Cross's nada and meditation that aims at a blank mind
The hermit "attempting to get closer to God in a way that forsakes their fellow man… is self indulgent."Tract 4 podcast, TP 8.0
"When we tell our children to pray to supernatural agents we tell them to pray to their distant descendants. This is not them talking to an imaginary entity… but instead a real being that will one day exist… Do we really think children are able to communicate with their distant descendants? No. However, we do believe that this framing… will create responses closer to God's will than attempting to directly model the will of God with the human mind."Tract 4, TP 8.0. Note what it claims: the responses are produced in the child's own mind, and the framing is chosen because it points them the right way.
"The Jesus you pray to and can reach God through is the part of God that lives in all true believing humans."Tract 10, TP 34.0.2
"Make sure when you're praying, you don't do it in a way that's overly performative, because that's really bad."Tract 12, TP 35.0.3; and Collins on Matthew 6: "not pray in a way that is performative and others can see it" (TP 35.0.4)
"Earth, which is now a purgatory, will be made a paradise, not by idle prayers and supplications, but by the efforts of man himself."Winwood Reade, The Martyrdom of Man, quoted in TPG 9.0
"There is going to be some truth that any individual that is among the elect can withdraw from their teachings by prayerfully investigating them."TPS 8.0, on other prophets. "Prayerfully investigating" here means careful, serious examination of a teaching, which is the proposal's kind of prayer: the truth is reached by your own reasoning, then tested by which groups it makes prosper (TP 38.0).
| Where | The text | What it shows | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Psalm 4:4 | "Stand in awe, and sin not: commune with your own heart upon your bed, and be still." | The proposal in one line: quiet, alone, thinking with your own heart. The page takes its name from it. | supports |
| Psalm 77:6 | "I commune with mine own heart: and my spirit made diligent search." | Prayer as a search: an honest going-over of one's life, done at night. | supports |
| Psalm 1:2 | "In his law doth he meditate day and night." | Hebrew hagah, to murmur over. Biblical meditation has an object (the law, your conduct); it is not emptying the mind. Matches TP 7.0. | supports |
| Ecclesiastes 5:2 | "Be not rash with thy mouth… for God is in heaven, and thou upon earth: therefore let thy words be few." | Distance and few words. Nothing here suggests God talks back. | supports |
| Mark 1:35 · Luke 5:16 · Luke 6:12 | "Rising up a great while before day, he went out, and departed into a solitary place, and there prayed." · "He withdrew himself into the wilderness, and prayed." · "Continued all night in prayer to God." | Jesus's habit, in the canon tier: set apart in time and place, alone. Set-apart is the word. | supports |
| Mark 12:38–40 | "Beware of the scribes… which devour widows' houses, and for a pretence make long prayers." | Canon-tier warning against prayer as a show. The well-known "enter into thy closet" line is Matthew 6:6, which sits in the elaboration tier; Mark carries the same warning on its own. | supports |
| Matthew 6:5–7 | "Enter into thy closet… pray to thy Father which is in secret… use not vain repetitions, as the heathen do." | The clearest text for private, unperformed prayer, and the corpus leans on it (TP 35.0.4). Elaboration tier, so it agrees with Mark rather than carrying the weight alone. | supports, lower tier |
| Luke 11:2–4 (Q) | "Our Father which art in heaven… Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done… Give us day by day our daily bread. And forgive us our sins; for we also forgive every one that is indebted to us. And lead us not into temptation." | The one prayer Jesus gives. It is addressed, and it asks; it never waits for an answer. Its parts map onto the proposal: the world and the future, daily needs and thanks, an accounting of wrongs done and forgiven, the choices ahead. | corrects: addressed |
| Mark 14:36 | "Abba, Father… take away this cup from me: nevertheless not what I will, but what thou wilt." | Jesus's hardest prayer. He asks and then submits; no voice answers in Mark. The prayer settles him, and he gets up and acts. | corrects: addressed |
| Mark 11:25 | "When ye stand praying, forgive, if ye have ought against any." | Prayer as the moment you deal with others: your grievances, their faults. | supports |
| Luke 18:10–14 | "The Pharisee stood and prayed thus with himself, God, I thank thee, that I am not as other men are… the publican… smote upon his breast, saying, God be merciful to me a sinner." | Two warnings in one. Thanks can become self-congratulation, so gratitude should not compare you favourably with others. And the bad prayer is the one prayed "with himself": the risk of purely private thought is that it only flatters you. | corrects: honest, not self-praising |
| Philippians 4:6 · 1 Thessalonians 5:17–18 | "In every thing by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known unto God." · "Pray without ceasing. In every thing give thanks." | The best texts for gratitude as part of prayer. Early-church tier: good counsel, not a command from Jesus. | supports, lower tier |
| 1 Timothy 2:1 · James 5:16 | "Supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks, be made for all men." · "Pray one for another." | Other people's troubles belong in prayer. Early-church tier. | supports, lower tier |
| Jeremiah 23:16, 26 · Ezekiel 13:3 | "They speak a vision of their own heart, and not out of the mouth of the LORD." · "prophets of the deceit of their own heart" · "Woe unto the foolish prophets, that follow their own spirit, and have seen nothing!" | The Bible's own diagnosis of the inner voice: what feels like God speaking is very often your own heart. It is the TP 8.0 argument, made by the prophets themselves. | supports: the danger |
| Jeremiah 17:9 | "The heart is deceitful above all things… who can know it?" | Why "it felt like God" proves nothing. | supports: the danger |
| Deuteronomy 18:21–22 · 1 John 4:1 | "If the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which the LORD hath not spoken." · "Believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God." | Even where the Bible allows that God speaks, a claimed word is tested by results, never trusted because it felt real. | supports: the danger |
The Bible is full of answered prayer, and some of the answers are spoken. An earlier version of this page undersold that. What the record shows is a pattern in who gets a spoken answer and how it arrives. Saul's failure lists the channels in one line: "the LORD answered him not, neither by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets" (1 Samuel 28:6).
| Where | Who prays | How the answer comes | Channel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Genesis 18:23–33 · Exodus 32:11–14, 33:11–23 | Abraham, Moses | Back-and-forth conversation. "The LORD spake unto Moses face to face, as a man speaketh unto his friend." | Spoken, to a founder-prophet |
| 1 Samuel 23:2–12 | David | "Shall I go…? And the LORD said unto David, Go." When he asks again he calls for the priest: "Bring hither the ephod" (23:9). The yes/no answers come through the priest's lots (Urim; compare Proverbs 16:33). | Lots, through a priest |
| 1 Kings 3:5–14 | Solomon | "In Gibeon the LORD appeared to Solomon in a dream by night." Solomon asks for wisdom and is answered in the dream. | Dream, to a king |
| 1 Samuel 1:10–20 | Hannah | She prays silently in the temple and hears nothing from God. Eli the priest says "the God of Israel grant thee thy petition", and later she has a son. | Another person, then the event |
| 2 Kings 20:1–6 | Hezekiah | The answer goes to Isaiah: "the word of the LORD came to him, saying, Turn again, and tell Hezekiah… I have heard thy prayer." | Through a prophet |
| 1 Kings 18:36–38 · Jonah 2 · Psalm 34:4 | Elijah, Jonah, the psalmist | Fire falls; the fish lets Jonah go; "I sought the LORD, and he heard me, and delivered me from all my fears." The answer is what happens, not words. | The event itself |
| Habakkuk 1–2 · Jeremiah 33:1–3 | Habakkuk, Jeremiah | "The LORD answered me, and said, Write the vision" (Hab 2:2). "Call unto me, and I will answer thee" is said to Jeremiah, a prophet in prison. | Spoken, to prophets |
| Daniel 9:20–23 | Daniel | "Whiles I was speaking in prayer, even the man Gabriel… touched me" and explained. | An angel, to a prophet |
| Mark 14:32–42 | Jesus, Gethsemane | He prays three times. Nothing answers. He gets up and goes to his arrest. (Luke 22:43's strengthening angel is missing from the oldest manuscripts.) | Silence (canon tier) |
| John 12:27–29 | Jesus | "Father, glorify thy name. Then came there a voice from heaven… I have both glorified it." The crowd hears it: some say "it thundered", others "an angel spake to him". | Audible voice, public (counsel tier) |
| Luke 3:21–22 · 9:28–35 | Jesus | At the baptism and the transfiguration Luke has Jesus praying when the voice comes. Mark tells both scenes (1:11, 9:7) with no prayer: the link to prayer is Luke's addition. | Voice from heaven (counsel tier) |
| Luke 1:13 · Acts 10:30–31 | Zacharias, Cornelius | "Thy prayer is heard", said by an angel. Cornelius is the one ordinary, non-prophet person in the record who gets a spoken reply. | Angel (counsel / early-church tier) |
| 2 Corinthians 12:8–9 | Paul | "I besought the Lord thrice… And he said unto me, My grace is sufficient for thee." A spoken answer, and a refusal. Context (12:1–10): Paul is answering rivals in Corinth who boast of visions. He calls boasting foolish, tells of being "caught up" to heaven where he "heard unspeakable words" he may not repeat, and says a "thorn in the flesh" was given him "lest I should be exalted above measure through the abundance of the revelations." He asked three times for it to go. The one word he does quote is no, and the reason: "my strength is made perfect in weakness." It is a refusal, not a rebuke for praying. Paul uses it to play down revelation-boasting, not to recommend seeking it. He also gives the test he wants used instead: he holds back his visions "lest any man should think of me above that which he seeth me to be, or that he heareth of me" (12:6), meaning judge me by what you see me do and hear me say. He does not deny that revelations happen; he claims them himself and also "signs, and wonders" (12:12). He denies that they count as credentials. Read beside Gethsemane (Mark 14), the two clearest prayers in the New Testament end the same way: asked three times, not granted, the one praying submits and carries on. "Hath said" (Greek eirēken, perfect tense) reads as a standing answer, and he says nothing about how he received it. | Claimed revelation (early-church tier) |
What the pattern shows. (0) Most of the spoken exchanges are not prayer as this page means it, a person setting time aside to address God. They are conversations God starts or prophets carry on (Abraham, Moses, Habakkuk), dreams, or enquiries through a priest. Counting only real prayers, someone choosing to pray: Hannah, Hezekiah, Elijah, Jonah and Jesus in Gethsemane hear no words; Daniel, Zacharias and Cornelius get an angel; Jesus in John 12 gets a public voice; Paul's "my grace is sufficient" is the one plain case of a person praying and being answered in words, and the answer is no. (1) Spoken answers to prayer go almost entirely to founders, prophets and kings (Abraham, Moses, Solomon, Habakkuk, Jeremiah, Daniel), to Jesus himself, and in Luke-Acts and Paul to a few others. (2) When an ordinary person prays, the answer comes through someone else (Eli, Isaiah), through the priest's lots, or as the thing that then happens. (3) Nowhere does the text tell ordinary believers to sit and listen for an inner voice. Where it talks about inner voices, it warns about them (Jeremiah 23, Ezekiel 13). (4) In the canon tier, the best example of Jesus praying, Gethsemane, gets silence. So the corpus is not saying God never spoke. In this tradition those answers are revelation given through prophets for their own time (TP 38.0), and every claimed word is tested by what it produces (Deuteronomy 18:22). What the corpus rejects is the ordinary believer expecting a personal reply today (TP 8.0). Below are the verses most often used to argue that every believer should expect one, and how this tradition reads them.
| Where | The text | The reading | Strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Samuel 3:10 | "Speak; for thy servant heareth." | Samuel is a prophet being called. In this tradition revelation comes through prophets, fitted to their time and people (TP 38.0), and is tested by what it produces. It is not offered as what every believer should expect in prayer. | answered |
| 1 Kings 19:12 | "And after the fire a still small voice." | The verse most often used to teach "listen for the quiet voice in prayer". It is Elijah, a prophet, at Horeb, and it is a single event. Read for what it is, it says God was not in the wind, the earthquake or the fire: not in the spectacular. Nothing in it is a general instruction. | answered |
| James 1:5 | "If any of you lack wisdom, let him ask of God… and it shall be given him." | The strongest text against the proposal. But it promises wisdom, not a voice, and the passage is about growing through trials (1:2–4). Asked for and received through careful thought, it is TPS 8.0's "prayerfully investigating". Maybe-true tier. | partly answered |
| Acts 10:9–10 · Acts 13:2 | Peter "went up upon the housetop to pray… he fell into a trance." · "The Holy Ghost said, Separate me Barnabas and Saul." | Early-church tier: what the first communities reported, weighed like any later church history, and under the house rule a claimed vision is not believed. Note too that the trance follows a skipped meal (10:10), the altered state Tract 5 warns about. | answered |
| John 10:27 | "My sheep hear my voice." | Counsel tier. In context the voice is Jesus's teaching heard by followers, not an inner voice in prayer. Read today, the voice is the words on the page. | answered |
Paul is up against rival teachers in Corinth (he calls them "super-apostles", 11:5, 12:11) who impress the church with their visions and revelations. He calls the boasting foolish, mentions his own trip to heaven reluctantly, and will not repeat what he heard. He asked three times for his "thorn in the flesh" to be taken away; the answer was no, "my strength is made perfect in weakness". So he will boast only of his weaknesses, and he asks to be judged "above that which he seeth me to be, or that he heareth of me" (12:6) by nothing more than what people can see him do and hear him say. Two limits on that reading: the answer is to Paul's own request, and turning it against revelation-boasting is Paul's use of it, a fair one but his. And he does not call his rivals' experiences fake: he claims a vision himself and "signs, and wonders, and mighty deeds" among the Corinthians (12:12). His point is that such things do not count as proof, not that they never happen. The rivals' boasts were about visions and status, not answered prayers as such.
A miracle story may be true or false, and for faith it does not matter which, because any of them could be invented, exaggerated, misremembered, staged or a lie, and no one can check it now. Something that could be fake cannot carry the weight of a faith. What can be checked is what happens to people who follow God's guidance: whether they and their children live, prosper, behave better and spread. That is how the tradition holds faith is confirmed: by the effects of following the guidance, not by wonders. On this reading Jesus is shown to be the Jewish messiah not by a virgin birth or an empty tomb, but by what came after him: a modified form of the law given to the Jews, carried to the whole world, and with it the end of leaving newborns to die.
"If he is the Jewish messiah and he took this set of laws that appears to make people more efficacious, more industrious, more moral, and spread it throughout the world, then that is the miracle, not the relatively minor miracles of his lifetime… when you overfocus on the miracles and whether or not they happened or the virgin birth and whether or not that happened, you miss the more important part."Malcolm Collins, Tract 27, TPS 86.2
"Christianity spread meant… at the very, very basic, the stop of infanticide. Billions of babies not left to die alone over the course of human history. How is that not obviously a bigger and more important and very easily verifiable miracle?… It was that women were not treated like trash… that when there was a plague in a town, people would stay and try to help their neighbors."Same episode, TPS 86.2, drawing on Rodney Stark's The Rise of Christianity (see TPS 37.0, TPS 38.0). "Billions" is the episode's estimate, not a count.
"There is a difference in outcomes, and that difference in outcomes is what affirms the truer understanding of the faith… By their fruits, you will know them."Same episode, TPS 86.2
| Where | The text | What it shows | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mark 8:11–12 | The Pharisees seek "a sign from heaven, tempting him… Verily I say unto you, There shall no sign be given unto this generation." | Canon tier. Jesus refuses to prove himself by a wonder when asked. | supports |
| Mark 13:22 | "False Christs and false prophets shall rise, and shall shew signs and wonders, to seduce, if it were possible, even the elect." | Canon tier. Wonders can come from liars, so a wonder proves nothing about who did it. | supports |
| Deuteronomy 13:1–3 · Exodus 7:11–12 | A prophet whose "sign or the wonder come to pass" but who says "Let us go after other gods": "thou shalt not hearken." · Pharaoh's magicians "also did in like manner with their enchantments." | The Torah's own rule: a sign that comes true still does not settle anything; what the person leads you to does. | supports |
| Luke 6:43–44 (Q) | "For every tree is known by his own fruit. For of thorns men do not gather figs." | Canon (Q). The test the corpus uses, in Jesus's words. | supports |
| Acts 5:38–39 | Gamaliel: "If this counsel or this work be of men, it will come to nought: But if it be of God, ye cannot overthrow it." | A test by outcome over time, offered by a rabbi. Early-church tier. | supports, lower tier |
| Isaiah 49:6 | "I will also give thee for a light to the Gentiles, that thou mayest be my salvation unto the end of the earth." | The messianic mark that can be checked: Israel's God known to the nations. About 2.3 billion people now worship the God of Israel as Christians. | supports |
| Luke 7:22 (Q) | Asked by John's disciples whether he is the one, Jesus answers: "the blind see, the lame walk… the dead are raised, to the poor the gospel is preached." | The strongest counter. Here Jesus does point to wonders, in the canon tier. It is a list of Isaiah's promises (35:5–6, 61:1) ending with the poor hearing the gospel, so it reads as a mission being carried out, but it plainly includes miracles. | cuts against |
| 1 Corinthians 15:14 · John 20:31 | "If Christ be not risen, then is our preaching vain." · "These are written, that ye might believe." | Paul and John rest faith on the resurrection and on signs. The corpus disagrees openly (TPS 86.2: the appearances after death "pretty ancillary"). An open collision, not settled here. | cuts against |
Leaving unwanted newborns out to die was ordinary in the Greco-Roman world. A husband writes to his wife in 1 BC: "if it is a boy, keep it; if a girl, cast it out" (Oxyrhynchus papyrus 744). Tacitus counted it as one of the odd habits of the Jews that "it is a crime among them to kill any newborn infant" (Histories 5.5). The earliest Christian rulebook says "thou shalt not… kill that which is begotten" (Didache 2.2); the Epistle to Diognetus (5.6) says Christians "beget children, but they do not cast away their offspring." Killing an infant became a capital crime in Roman law in 374, under Christian emperors (Theodosian Code 9.14.1). This is the kind of evidence the tradition counts, because it can be checked in the record and no one has to take a witness's word for it.
The argument. This is not about what God can do. A God able to make a universe could speak to anyone at any time. The point is what would follow if he set up spoken answers to prayer as the normal way he deals with people. From that moment, anyone could say "God told me", and nobody else could check it. The claim would become the strongest lever one person can hold over another, because whoever believes it cannot refuse without refusing God, and the people most open to it are the ones trying hardest to be faithful. A God who understood human nature, and this tradition does not believe God is a fool, would foresee that and would not lend his name to it. So he speaks in ways a community can check: the written record, testable predictions, and the visible results of following his guidance over generations. This is the same reason Exhibit D gives for why miracles prove nothing.
One branch of Christianity has run the experiment. Mainstream Christianity has always had its mystics and self-proclaimed prophets, but the Latter-day Saint tradition is the one that teaches, in its own scriptures, that every believer should expect God to answer prayer with a felt or heard reply.
"Ask God… if these things are not true; and if ye shall ask with a sincere heart, with real intent, having faith in Christ, he will manifest the truth of it unto you, by the power of the Holy Ghost."Book of Mormon, Moroni 10:4
"You must study it out in your mind; then you must ask me if it be right, and if it is right I will cause that your bosom shall burn within you; therefore, you shall feel that it is right."Doctrine and Covenants 9:8 (1829). See also 8:2: "I will tell you in your mind and in your heart, by the Holy Ghost."
Tract 4 names this as the point where Techno-Puritanism parts from Mormonism: "Just go personally pray on it and God will tell you the right answer, where I don't think that that's how God communicates with people" (TP 8.0).
"Thou shalt take thy brother, Hiram Page, between him and thee alone, and tell him that those things which he hath written from that stone are not of me and that Satan deceiveth him."D&C 28:11 (1830). Months after the church was founded, a second member was receiving revelations, and the answer was a revelation that "no one shall be appointed to receive commandments and revelations in this church excepting my servant Joseph Smith" (28:2). A rule like that only settles anything if you trust the person who received it.
"If she will not abide this commandment she shall be destroyed, saith the Lord." · "Then shall she believe and administer unto him, or she shall be destroyed, saith the Lord your God."D&C 132:54, 64 (dictated 1843). The revelation on plural marriage, addressed in part to Joseph Smith's wife Emma, telling her to accept his other wives. It is still canonized LDS scripture.
"During the third and final appearance, the angel came with a drawn sword, threatening Joseph with destruction unless he went forward and obeyed the commandment fully." · Helen Mar Kimball "was sealed to Joseph several months before her 15th birthday."The church's own Gospel Topics essay, "Plural Marriage in Kirtland and Nauvoo"
The cases below come from fundamentalist offshoots or from people the mainstream church excommunicated and condemned. They are not the LDS church's actions. But each man used the church's own teaching that God answers personally, and each found people who had been taught to obey that kind of answer.
| Case | What the "revelation" did | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Ron and Dan Lafferty, Utah, 1984 | In March 1984 Ron wrote down a revelation beginning "Thus saith the Lord unto my servants the prophets", ordering the "removal" of his sister-in-law Brenda and her baby Erica. On 24 July 1984 the brothers killed them both. | Deseret News, 2004; Deseret News, 1996 |
| Brian David Mitchell, Utah, 2002 | He took 14-year-old Elizabeth Smart from her bed at knifepoint and held her as his "wife" for nine months. Police reported he told them "The Lord God delivered her" to him. Smart testified in 2010 that she watched him "proclaim that he was God's servant and called to do God's work", which she knew was "something that… God would not tell somebody to do." | CNN, 15 Nov 2010; AP via Fox News, 10 Nov 2010 |
| Warren Jeffs, FLDS, 2000s | He ruled his sect by revelations in "thus saith the Lord" form. In 2004 he expelled about twenty men, including the town's mayor, and reassigned their wives and children to other men. He was convicted in Texas in 2011 of sexually assaulting girls he had taken as "spiritual wives". | Warren Jeffs (Wikipedia); NBC News, 2011 |
| Chad Daybell and Lori Vallow, Idaho, 2019 | Daybell, an author of LDS end-times novels, claimed visions and told his circle that his wife Tammy and Lori's children Tylee (16) and JJ (7) had become "dark" spirits or "zombies". All three were killed. Vallow was sentenced to life without parole in 2023, and Daybell to death on 1 June 2024. | Fox 10, trial testimony; East Idaho News, June 2024 |
The church's own leaders have had to deal with it. Dallin H. Oaks, now the church's president, speaking at BYU in 1981:
"I have heard of cases where a young man told a young woman she should marry him because he had received a revelation that she was to be his eternal companion. If this is a true revelation, it will be confirmed directly to the woman if she seeks to know. In the meantime, she is under no obligation to heed it… The man can receive revelation to guide his own actions, but he cannot properly receive revelation to direct hers. She is outside his stewardship."Dallin H. Oaks, "Revelation", BYU devotional, 29 September 1981. In the same talk: "Satan is a great deceiver, and he is the source of some of these spurious revelations. Others are simply imagined."
How ordinary it is. No one has counted how often it happens, but it is common enough that the church's own university has words for it. Nineteen years after Oaks's talk, a BYU marriage professor was still quoting his advice to students (Thomas B. Holman, BYU devotional, 1 August 2000, noting that "most Latter-day Saints want a spiritual confirmation" in choosing a spouse). BYU's own student paper, in 2016:
"We get stalkers who just have very poor social skills, we have the religious guys who believe God told them to marry this girl… And sometimes those two merge: the social skills and the religious angle."BYU University Police Lt. Arnold Lemmon, in Isaac Wright, "'Revelation' to marry can lead to stalking", BYU Daily Universe, 10 February 2016. The article says BYU's cases of "religious stalking" typically involve "men who have experienced some sort of 'spiritual answer' telling them they are destined to marry a particular woman", and that the director of BYU's marriage and family therapy clinic had heard of "plenty of these cases" (the reporter's words).
"A man is supposed to be the head of the household and receive revelation… It made me feel pressured; he said he'd received a revelation so I felt I needed to receive one."A BYU freshman, same article. Another student describes a man who believed God had confirmed she was the girl he would marry, though they were not even dating: "he continued to message me, even though I wasn't responding."
What the fix shows. Oaks's answer is decent advice, and it concedes the point. Once personal revelation is taught, the church needs a second rule, "stewardship", to limit whose revelations count over whom. The rule does not take the lever away. It leaves it with whoever already has authority: the husband over the household, the bishop over the ward, the president over the church. In D&C 132:64, that is exactly where the revelation lands. And the young woman in Oaks's example is told to settle it by seeking her own revelation, so the only check on a claimed voice is another claimed voice. This is the trap Tract 4 describes: "how very convenient that God had a penchant for her preferred indulgences" (TP 8.0).
| Where | The text | What it shows | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jeremiah 23:34, 36 | "The prophet, and the priest, and the people, that shall say, The burden of the LORD, I will even punish that man and his house… the burden of the LORD shall ye mention no more: for every man's word shall be his burden." | God forbids people from even saying they carry his word, because they had been using it for themselves. Whatever you say is your own word, and you answer for it. | supports |
| Deuteronomy 18:20–22 | "The prophet, which shall presume to speak a word in my name, which I have not commanded him to speak… even that prophet shall die." | Claiming God's voice falsely was a capital crime. The law treats it as one of the most dangerous things a person can do. | supports |
| Mark 13:6, 21–22 | "Many shall come in my name… and shall deceive many… if any man shall say to you, Lo, here is Christ… believe him not." | Canon tier. Jesus's own instruction: do not believe a claim to speak with divine authority because it is made. | supports |
| Deuteronomy 19:15 · 1 Corinthians 14:29 | "At the mouth of two witnesses, or at the mouth of three witnesses, shall the matter be established." · "Let the prophets speak two or three, and let the other judge." | A community check: no single person's word settles anything, and even in Paul's churches a claimed prophecy was judged by the others present. | supports |
| Numbers 11:29 · Joel 2:28 (Acts 2:17) | "Would God that all the LORD's people were prophets." · "Your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, your old men shall dream dreams." | The counter. These hope for, or promise, a time when everyone receives the spirit, which is the LDS reading. In context, Moses's line is a wish, and Joel's is a promise about a coming day. Neither tells a believer today to take a felt answer as a command, or to give one to someone else. | cuts against |
What God gives instead: things a community can check. The corpus describes this model directly: "it's the personal responsibility of every individual to come to these truths on their own, and that truth is more efficiently achieved through large groups of individuals coming to these truths on their own, and then God showing which truths were actually true by which of those individuals end up influencing the future" (TPS 8.0; also TP 38.0: "God rewards groups that understand Him best with cultural prosperity"). A text anyone can read, an argument anyone can test, a result anyone can see in how families and nations fare. None of these can be used by one person to claim another person's body, marriage or obedience.
Even if God does speak to you, you may not cite it as your authority to overrule anyone else. In any disagreement, a claimed word from God, a prompting, a dream or a "confirmation" counts as your own opinion and nothing more. It has to win by argument and evidence the other person can check, or it does not win. A husband cannot use it on a wife, a parent on a grown child, a suitor on a woman, a leader on a member, or the other way round. The person who says it carries it as their own word: "every man's word shall be his burden" (Jeremiah 23:36). Where it may be right, it can still guide your own choices. Even the LDS stewardship rule concedes the core of this, but it leaves the lever with whoever already holds authority. This tradition does not make that exception. Stated as the house position by Malcolm Collins, 14 November 2026; grounded in Jeremiah 23:33–36, Deuteronomy 18:20, Mark 13:21, 1 Corinthians 14:29 and TP 8.0.
In one paragraph. The Torah never commands prayer in so many words. Jesus does: "Watch ye and pray" (Mark 14:38, 13:33), and "When ye pray, say…" (Luke 11:2, Q), which assumes his followers will. So it is expected of a follower. What is not commanded anywhere is a posture, a time of day, a length or a number of times. The Bible shows people praying standing, kneeling, sitting, face-down and lying in bed. Kneeling by the bed with hands clasped is a later custom: the clasped hands come from medieval homage to a lord (TPG 19.4), and the children's bedside prayer comes from 18th-century primers. The house position (Malcolm Collins, 14 November 2026) treats prayer like the Sabbath in small: a regular break, taken at an unusual time and in an unusual position, so that it is set apart from ordinary thinking and you can think your life through. The scripture supports the break and leaves the form free.
Scripture fixes no posture, time, length, count, words or place, and this tradition does not add any. The form is meant to be as flexible as possible, so each person finds what actually works for them. There is one requirement: it must not look like ordinary life. Sitting at your desk in front of the computer, in the chair you work in, with a screen open, is the state prayer is meant to get you out of, so that does not count. Anything that clearly breaks that run counts: lying on the floor, sitting on the stairs before anyone is up, standing at a dark window, walking a route you walk only for this, kneeling if that is what marks it for you, lying awake in bed. Change the time, the place or the position, or all three, until your mind registers "this is not work and not routine". Then keep that as your habit. If it stops feeling set apart, change it. House position, Malcolm Collins, 14 November 2026. Biblical range of postures in the table below; the Sabbath logic underneath.
| Where | The text | What it settles |
|---|---|---|
| Torah | No verse says "pray". The nearest is Deuteronomy 11:13, "to serve him with all your heart"; the Talmud asks "What is service of the heart? This is prayer" (Taanit 2a). | Prayer as a Torah duty is a rabbinic reading. Maimonides counts it as a commandment, but says the number, form and times of prayer are not from the Torah (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Prayer 1:1–3). Nachmanides denies it is a Torah commandment at all. The three daily services are rabbinic custom. |
| Daniel 6:10 · Psalm 55:17 | "He kneeled upon his knees three times a day, and prayed, and gave thanks… as he did aforetime." · "Evening, and morning, and at noon, will I pray." | A regular habit, described and admired, but not commanded. |
| Mark 14:38 · Mark 13:33 | "Watch ye and pray, lest ye enter into temptation." · "Take ye heed, watch and pray: for ye know not when the time is." | Canon tier, imperative. Jesus tells his followers to pray, and ties it to staying alert and resisting temptation. |
| Luke 11:2 (Q) · Luke 18:1 | "When ye pray, say, Our Father…" · "Men ought always to pray, and not to faint." | Q assumes prayer and gives its shape; Luke (counsel tier) urges persistence. Neither sets a time or a form. |
| Posture | Where | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Standing | "When ye stand praying" (Mark 11:25); Hannah "stood… praying" (1 Samuel 1:26); the publican "standing afar off" (Luke 18:13) | The ordinary Jewish posture. The central Jewish prayer is still called the Amidah, "the standing". |
| Kneeling | Daniel 6:10; Jesus "kneeled down, and prayed" (Luke 22:41); Acts 20:36 | Used in earnest or at a parting, not as the default. |
| Face to the ground | Jesus "fell on the ground, and prayed" (Mark 14:35); Elijah "put his face between his knees" (1 Kings 18:42) | In a crisis, the body goes somewhere it does not normally go. |
| Sitting | "Then went king David in, and sat before the LORD" (2 Samuel 7:18) | David's prayer of thanks after the promise of a dynasty. |
| Lying in bed | "Commune with your own heart upon your bed" (Psalm 4:4); "when I… meditate on thee in the night watches" (Psalm 63:6) | The night-time, horizontal version: the closest to the proposal. |
| Hands raised | "Lifting up holy hands" (1 Timothy 2:8); Psalm 141:2 | Early-church and psalm custom. |
| Kneeling at the bed, hands clasped | Not in the Bible. | Clasped hands come from the feudal homage gesture (TPG 19.4: the vassal kneels and puts his joined hands between his lord's). The bedside children's prayer "Now I lay me down to sleep" was spread by the 18th-century New England Primer. |
The Sabbath is a commanded stop: the Hebrew shabat means "cease" more than "rest" (TPS 73.1; see The Seventh Day). It works because it breaks the run of ordinary days. Prayer, on this reading, is the same thing in small: a regular stop that breaks the run of ordinary thinking. What makes it work is that it is set apart, and the people in the text mark that with their bodies and the clock: before dawn in a solitary place (Mark 1:35), all night on a mountain (Luke 6:12), face to the ground (Mark 14:35), in bed in the night watches (Psalm 63:6). So the house practice fixes the habit and leaves the form free. Choose a time and a position you do not otherwise use, for a regular stretch, and think your life through in it. The one limit comes from Exhibit A: the unusual position is there to mark the time off, not to change your state of mind. Nothing about it should make you dizzy, short of sleep, hungry or entranced.
Many ordinary, healthy people will at some point hear a voice that is not there. How many depends on what is counted, from about one person in twenty for clear hallucinations to most people for a brief voice or their name called. A quarter is a fair middle figure, though no single study gives exactly that. Such experiences cluster in exactly the conditions religious life creates: the edge of sleep, grief, long solitary prayer, fasting and sleep loss, and above all prayer practised in the expectation of hearing God. A tradition that teaches "God will answer you" therefore has a ready supply of sincere believers who will one day hear something, and who have been taught to obey it. No bad actor is needed for this to go wrong.
| Study | Figure | What was counted |
|---|---|---|
| McGrath et al., JAMA Psychiatry 2015 | 5.2% lifetime | Any hallucination, in a WHO survey of 31,261 adults in 18 countries; most people had it only once or a few times. The strictest, largest count. Summary |
| Beavan, Read & Cartwright, Journal of Mental Health 2011 | 13.2% median | Hearing voices, across the general-population studies in a literature review; the studies ranged from 0.6% to 84% depending on the question asked. PubMed |
| Ohayon et al., 1996 | 37% | Hallucinations while falling asleep, in a representative UK sample of 4,972 people (12.5% on waking). Night-time prayer in bed falls in this zone. |
| Rees, BMJ 1971 | about 13% heard them | Of 293 widowed people in Wales, almost half had hallucinations or a sense of the dead spouse's presence; about 13% heard the spouse's voice. Rees called these normal. |
| Posey & Losch, 1983 | 71% | College students (375) who had ever had a brief voice experience while awake, such as hearing their name called; about 10% had heard a comforting or advising voice that did not feel like their own thoughts. The high figure includes borderline experiences. Abstract |
| T. M. Luhrmann, When God Talks Back (2012) | trainable | An anthropologist's study of evangelical churches that teach members to hear God, with a controlled experiment. People given a month of imaginative prayer practice reported more vivid imagery and more unusual sensory experiences than a control group that studied the gospels. Hearing God is partly a skill a practice can train. Summary |
Yes. Expectation and practice change what people perceive, and what they are taught decides whose voice they think it is. Four lines of research:
| Study | What it found | What it means here |
|---|---|---|
| Luhrmann, Nusbaum & Thisted, "The absorption hypothesis: learning to hear God in evangelical Christianity", American Anthropologist 112:1 (2010) | In a Vineyard church that teaches members to hear God, the people who scored high on "absorption" (a trait first measured in hypnosis research: the capacity to be lost in imagination) were far more likely to report hearing God's voice and other sensory experiences. Low scorers often found prayer unrewarding because God never seemed to speak to them. (Science News reported the sample as 28 congregants.) Paper | Who "hears God" tracks a measurable trait of imagination, not faithfulness. |
| Luhrmann & Morgain, "Prayer as inner sense cultivation", Ethos 40:4 (2012) | A randomized trial. One group spent 30 minutes a day for a month on imaginative prayer, attending to inner experience in search of God; the control group listened to lectures on the gospels. The prayer group reported sharper mental imagery, more unusual sensory experiences, more intense spiritual experiences, and more hallucination-like experiences. Paper (post-print) | A month of the kind of prayer that listens for God produced more of the experiences people then report as God. The practice makes the experience. |
| Powers, Mathys & Corlett, "Pavlovian conditioning-induced hallucinations result from overweighting of perceptual priors", Science 357 (2017) | People were shown a picture paired with a faint tone until they expected it; then the tone was dropped. Many went on hearing it. Voice-hearers, both psychiatric patients and healthy self-described "psychics" who heard voices, heard the absent tone most, driven by strong expectations. Many of the psychics took their voices as a gift. Paper | The brain can hear what it has learned to expect. Teach someone to expect a voice in prayer, and you are running this experiment on them. |
| Luhrmann et al., "Differences in voice-hearing experiences of people with psychosis in the USA, India and Ghana", British Journal of Psychiatry 206 (2015) | Sixty people with schizophrenia, twenty each in California, Chennai and Accra. In California the voices were mostly harsh and violent. In Chennai they were often relatives giving advice. In Accra most people heard God. Stanford summary | Even in illness, culture decides who the voice is. A person raised to expect God's voice will hear an illness speak as God. |
Taken together, these say that a tradition teaching "listen and God will speak" is not neutral. It selects the people most prone to absorption, trains their perception with the practice, and supplies the name the voice will take. None of this proves God never speaks. It shows that the experience people are taught to treat as proof of his voice is one that practice, expectation and culture produce on their own, so it cannot serve as proof of anything.
Why it is dangerous even when no one means harm. (1) The voice uses your own material. It speaks with your worries, your hopes and the words you already know. That is Tract 4's point about the God people model: it says what they wanted to hear (TP 8.0). (2) It comes when judgment is weakest: grief, exhaustion, falling asleep, fasting, crisis. Those are the very conditions Tract 5 warns are used to break people down (TP 6.0). (3) Calling it God takes away your ability to question it. An odd thought can be weighed and dismissed. A command from God cannot be refused without refusing God. (4) Practice can produce it. If a church trains people to hear God, it will produce people who hear something, and the church cannot tell which of them heard God. (5) It can be the first sign of illness. For a small number of people, voices are an early sign of a psychotic illness that needs treatment. Treating them as revelation delays the treatment and can make the illness worse. The Bible already warns about the dream and the inner voice: "I have dreamed, I have dreamed… prophets of the deceit of their own heart" (Jeremiah 23:25–26). The house rule, then: if you ever hear a voice, it is an experience to note and, if it recurs, to mention to a doctor. It is never a command, and never authority over anyone (Exhibit E).
Yes. The Bible says plainly that the devil and deceiving spirits can come to people in God's name. Satan "is transformed into an angel of light" (2 Corinthians 11:14). A spirit volunteers to be "a lying spirit in the mouth of all his prophets", and they go on saying "Thus saith the LORD" (1 Kings 22:22). The church is told to "try the spirits whether they are of God" (1 John 4:1) and warned of people "giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils" (1 Timothy 4:1). Even an angel preaching something else is to be "accursed" (Galatians 1:8). And a prophet whose sign comes true is still not to be followed, because "the LORD your God proveth you" (Deuteronomy 13:1–3). One precision: no scene has Satan say the words "I am God" to someone. What the text shows instead is worse, because it is how it actually happens: the false word arrives as a message from God, through a messenger, an angel or a prophet, and sincere people believe it. The cases are below; each reference links to the King James text.
| Where | The text | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| 1 John 4:1 · 1 Timothy 4:1 | "Believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world." · "Some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils." | Spirits that are not from God speak to believers, and it does not show from the inside. The instruction is to test every one, not to trust the experience. |
| 2 Thessalonians 2:9–11 | "Whose coming is after the working of Satan with all power and signs and lying wonders… they should believe a lie." | Satan's work comes with signs that convince. Early-church tier. |
| Deuteronomy 13:1–3 | "If there arise among you a prophet, or a dreamer of dreams… and the sign or the wonder come to pass… thou shalt not hearken… for the LORD your God proveth you." | Even a true sign from a dreamer does not prove the message. What matters is where it leads you. |
| 1 Kings 13:11–24 | An old prophet tells the man of God: "I am a prophet also as thou art; and an angel spake unto me by the word of the LORD, saying, Bring him back… But he lied unto him." The man believes him, eats, and is killed by a lion on the road. | The closest case. A faithful man drops what God told him because a fellow believer claims an angel's message. He dies for it, and the liar is not the one who pays. |
| 1 Kings 22:6–24 | Four hundred prophets tell the king "the Lord shall deliver it", and Zedekiah adds "Thus saith the LORD." The scene in heaven: "I will be a lying spirit in the mouth of all his prophets." Zedekiah, struck by Micaiah, asks: "Which way went the Spirit of the LORD from me to speak unto thee?" | Sincere prophets, sure they speak for God, are carrying a lying spirit, and the king dies following them. Zedekiah's question shows he truly believed it. |
| 2 Samuel 24:1 · 1 Chronicles 21:1 | "He [the LORD] moved David against them to say, Go, number Israel." · "And Satan stood up against Israel, and provoked David to number Israel." | The same urging to the same act is put down to God in one book and to Satan in the other. Even the Bible's own writers could not agree where it came from. |
| Mark 8:33 | To Peter, who meant well: "Get thee behind me, Satan: for thou savourest not the things that be of God, but the things that be of men." | Canon tier. A loving, sincere voice from Jesus's closest friend gets the name Satan, because it carries human wishes as if they were God's. |
| Luke 4:9–11 | The devil quotes scripture to Jesus (Psalm 91: "He shall give his angels charge over thee"). | The tempter speaks in God's own words. Elaboration tier (Q3). |
| 2 Corinthians 11:13–15 · Galatians 1:8 | "Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light." · "Though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel… let him be accursed." | Paul's warning: the most dangerous deceiver looks like God's messenger, so even an angel is to be judged by what it says. |
Tract 24 names the danger of Genesis 22 directly: "god establishing a precedent that… you might hear a voice in your head. Like, is it a good thing in a religious tradition to have a precedent that if you hear a voice in your head telling you to kill your kids, maybe you should?… Especially given that, like, multiple people have acted on this." And its answer: "if you're a good Christian and one day you started hearing a voice telling you that god wants you to sacrifice your child, I would presume the good Christian thing to assume is that's actually the devil testing you" (TPS 83.1, which goes on to argue how the story should be read).
God settles it in the prophets, in words that leave no room: they "burn their sons with fire for burnt offerings unto Baal, which I commanded not, nor spake it, neither came it into my mind" (Jeremiah 19:5; again at 7:31; Deuteronomy 12:31 calls it what other nations do "to their gods"). Any voice that commands it is, by God's own statement, not God. Immanuel Kant drew the same conclusion in 1798: Abraham should have answered the voice, "That I ought not to kill my good son is quite certain. But that you, this apparition, are God — of that I am not certain, and never can be, even if this voice rings down to me from (visible) heaven" (The Conflict of the Faculties, Ak. 7:63, Gregor translation).
These are not stories about wicked people. Each was sick, and by every account sincere: they heard a voice and believed it was God. Courts found both women legally insane. In a tradition that teaches God speaks to you in prayer, and that holds up Abraham's readiness as the model of faith, an illness like this has a ready-made script.
| Case | What happened | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Deanna Laney, New Chapel Hill, Texas, May 2003 | A devout mother who believed God had ordered her to kill her sons. She killed Joshua (8) and Luke (6) with rocks, and left Aaron (14 months) brain-damaged. In April 2004 a jury found her not guilty by reason of insanity. Three forensic psychiatrists, including the prosecution's, tied it to delusional "urgings from God". | Wikipedia; NBC News / AP, April 2004 |
| Dena Schlosser, Plano, Texas, November 2004 | She cut off the arms of her ten-month-old daughter Margaret, who died, saying she heard God command it, and testified that she wanted to give her baby to God. She had postpartum psychosis. After a mistrial, she was found not guilty by reason of insanity in 2006. | Wikipedia; NBC News, 2006 |
The human cost of making it normal. Exhibit G shows that some of the faithful will one day hear a voice: from grief, sleeplessness, the edge of sleep, a new baby or illness. What happens next depends on what they were taught. Teach them that God speaks in prayer, that his voice can override conscience and that obeying it like Abraham is the height of faith, and an illness gets a script, a family gets no warning, and the people closest to her cannot argue her out of it. Teach them that God does not command child sacrifice and never speaks this way, that a voice is a symptom to bring to a doctor, and that no voice is authority over anyone, and the same illness meets a ready answer: "that is not God." Every one of these mothers was trying to be faithful. A tradition is answerable for the scripts it hands them.
No other tradition holds the whole position, but almost every part of it has serious company. The rejection of new personal revelation is official Reformed doctrine, and the original Puritans enforced it. The warning against seeking voices and visions is classic Catholic and Orthodox mystical teaching. Prayer as a reflexive act that works on the one who prays is Kant's view and the Reconstructionist Jewish one. The "do not cite your impressions as authority" rule has a near-exact twin in modern cessationist preaching. What is distinctive to this tradition is the combination: addressing one's descendants, testing faith by its fruits across generations, and holding all of it with a God who is real and acts.
The table below gives each source, with links, and where each one parts ways with this tradition.
| Who | What they say | How close, and where they differ |
|---|---|---|
| Reformed churches: the Westminster Confession, 1646 | "Those former ways of God's revealing his will unto his people being now ceased" (1.1); nothing is to be added to scripture "whether by new revelations of the Spirit, or traditions of men" (1.6). Text | Close on the main point: no new revelation for believers. Scholars still argue over how far 1.1 goes. The difference: they shut the door by closing the canon, not by the manipulation argument. |
| The Puritans: Anne Hutchinson's trial, Boston, 1637 | Hutchinson told the court she knew God's will by immediate revelation, "by the voice of his own spirit to my soul". The Massachusetts court banished her. NPS | The namesakes of this tradition faced this exact question and ruled against the private voice. The difference: they enforced it by banishment. This tradition's rule is only that a claimed voice carries no authority over others. |
| Catholic: John of the Cross, Ascent of Mount Carmel, c. 1580 | Whoever would "seek any vision or revelation" now "would not only be acting foolishly, but would be committing an offence against God, by not setting his eyes altogether upon Christ". Book II, ch. 22 | Close on not seeking voices. The difference: his path is emptying the mind (the nada), which Tract 5 rejects by name (TP 7.0). |
| Catholic: Ignatius of Loyola; the Catechism | Rules for discernment: "It is a mark of the evil spirit to assume the appearance of an angel of light." Catechism §67: private revelations are not part of the faith, and "it is not their role to improve or complete Christ's definitive Revelation." Catechism, §67 | Agrees that a voice may be the enemy dressed as light. The difference: Rome still approves some private revelations (Lourdes, Fátima) through church judgment. |
| Orthodox: the teaching on prelest (spiritual delusion) | The Fathers advise never to believe a vision or accept it quickly as true. Ignatius Brianchaninov warns that prayer worked through the imagination often ends in delusion, even insanity. OrthodoxWiki | Very close on the danger, and it treats seeking experiences as the trap. The difference: it is a monastic discipline for the advanced, not a rule for every household. |
| Immanuel Kant, Religion within the Bounds of Mere Reason, 1793 | Prayer thought of as a service that works on God is "a superstitious delusion (a fetish-making)". Its real value is the spirit of prayer: a moral disposition kept alive in the one who prays. SEP In 1798 he added that Abraham could never be certain the voice was God (Exhibit H). | The closest philosopher. Prayer works on you, not on God, and no voice is certain. The difference: Kant leaves little room for a God who acts in history. This tradition reads God's action in the fruits. |
| Reconstructionist Judaism (Mordecai Kaplan) | Prayer as an energizing of the spirit that lifts a person intellectually and ethically, not a petition. Its writers note the Hebrew verb for praying is reflexive, something done to oneself. Reconstructing Judaism | Close on what prayer does. The difference: many Reconstructionists do not believe God hears prayer at all. This tradition still addresses God. |
| Evangelical "wisdom view": Garry Friesen (1980), Bruce Waltke (1995), Kevin DeYoung (2009) | God has no hidden individual plan to decode through feelings or signs. Decide by scripture's moral will and wisdom. Waltke: "finding" God's will in this sense "is really a form of divination." Waltke summary | Very close on guidance: you decide by wisdom, not by waiting for a sign. The difference: it does not develop the community and generational test. |
| John MacArthur, Strange Fire (2013) | "Since no one can identify with absolute certainty the source of the impressions he experiences, he must not ascribe authority to them or rely upon them as direction from God." (Grace to You, Strange Fire Q&A, as quoted in conference coverage.) | Almost word for word the rule in Exhibit E. The difference: his argument is cessationist (the gifts ended with the apostles), not about manipulation. |
| Quakers: the clearness committee | A person who feels led meets a small group that asks questions over time before anything is acted on. | Starts from the opposite place, the inner light, but arrived at the same safeguard: no leading is acted on without others testing it. |
The opposing position has serious defenders: Pentecostal and charismatic Christianity (the fastest-growing part of the faith), Dallas Willard's Hearing God (1984) and Jack Deere's Surprised by the Voice of God (1996). Their arguments: (1) Joel 2:28 and Acts 2:17 promise the Spirit to "all flesh", sons and daughters prophesying, and no verse says that ended. The cessationist reading of "when that which is perfect is come" (1 Corinthians 13:10) is contested. (2) "My sheep hear my voice" (John 10:27): a God who is personal speaks personally. (3) Their own safeguards, testing every word against scripture and the church, already answer the abuse problem. Willard's own test is closer to this tradition than it looks. He held that a word from God never overrides scripture or wisdom, and should be weighed with others.
1. The promise of the Spirit is a promise of God's presence and care, not of a voice you will hear. In Hebrew, the Spirit is ruach, breath and wind. In the prophets, God putting his spirit in people means giving them life and setting them right: "I… shall put my spirit in you, and ye shall live" (Ezekiel 37:14); "I will put my spirit within you, and cause you to walk in my statutes" (Ezekiel 36:27). The evidence of that spirit is conduct, not sound. Joel's promise follows a promise of rain, harvest and restored plenty (Joel 2:23–29): God's protection over a whole people. The New Testament names the Spirit the paraklētos, the advocate called to stand beside you, who will "abide with you for ever" (John 14:16). It measures him by his fruit: "love, joy, peace, longsuffering, gentleness, goodness, faith" (Galatians 5:22–23). Nothing in that list is heard. All of it can be seen by others, which is the test Exhibit D uses.
2. "My sheep hear my voice" is a parable about following his teaching, and the Greek words show it. The word for voice is phōnē. It means sound or voice, but also a language or what a voice says: Paul uses it for the world's languages, "so many kinds of voices in the world" (1 Corinthians 14:10–11). "Hear" is akouō, which with this construction regularly means to heed or obey, as the Hebrew shema means both "hear" and "obey". The verse says what the hearing is: "My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me" (John 10:27). John flags the whole shepherd passage as a figure of speech: "This parable spake Jesus unto them" (10:6, Greek paroimia, a figurative saying). Two verses earlier Jesus gives his own evidence, and it is not a voice: "the works that I do in my Father's name, they bear witness of me" (10:25). He says it again to Pilate: "Every one that is of the truth heareth my voice" (18:37), meaning whoever loves the truth recognises his message. His sheep "hear his voice" the way we now can: by recognising his teaching and following it. And even on the charismatic reading, this tradition's rule still applies. If you do believe you have heard him, that belief gives you no authority over anyone. So it is not something to use in an argument with anyone else (Exhibit E).
3. "Test it against scripture" does not stop the abuse, because the most common abuse fits inside scripture. The everyday Mormon case is a man telling a woman that God says she should marry him (Exhibit E). Marrying and having children breaks no verse. "Be fruitful, and multiply" is the first command in the Bible (Genesis 1:28), and "whoso findeth a wife findeth a good thing" (Proverbs 18:22). The claimed revelation passes every scriptural test and still takes from her the one thing that matters: her own free choice. The larger cases pass too. The 1843 plural-marriage revelation justifies itself from scripture, naming "Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob; as also Moses, David and Solomon" and their many wives (D&C 132:1). A mother who hears she must give up her child has Genesis 22 in her Bible. A scripture test only filters out a voice that orders something scripture forbids. The danger is a voice that orders something scripture permits, aimed at a particular person, carrying God's name. Only the rule in Exhibit E reaches that case: no voice is ever authority over another person.
A proposal built from the exhibits, not yet a tract. Each step names the text it rests on.
No expectation of God's voice; seeking one is dangerous. Said in so many words in Tract 4 and Tract 6, argued in the Pragmatist's Guide, and made by Jeremiah and Ezekiel about the voice of one's own heart. The Bible has many answered prayers, some answered in words, but the spoken answers go to prophets, kings and Jesus. Ordinary people get theirs through another person, the lots, or what happens next, and the inner voice is warned against (Exhibit C).
Quiet, set apart, alone, not performed. Jesus's habit in Mark and Luke, Psalm 4:4, Ecclesiastes 5:2, the warning about long prayers in Mark 12; Matthew 6 agrees from the elaboration tier.
"Thinking to yourself." The prayers in the text are addressed: "Our Father", "Abba". The Pharisee who "prayed with himself" is the bad example. So keep the address, to God or to your descendants as the corpus teaches, and drop only the wait for an answer.
Faith is confirmed by the effects of following God's guidance, not by miracles or answered-prayer stories. Any wonder could be fake, so true or not it cannot settle anything. Tract 27 (TPS 86.2) says so; Mark 8:12 and 13:22, Deuteronomy 13 and the Q saying "every tree is known by his own fruit" agree. The clearest answered prayer, Paul's, is a refusal he uses against revelation-boasting. Luke 7:22, 1 Corinthians 15:14 and John 20:31 cut against it (Exhibit D).
Jesus tells his followers to pray ("watch and pray", Mark 14:38); nothing sets the posture, time or count. The Bible shows standing, kneeling, sitting, face-down and lying in bed. Clasped hands at the bedside are medieval and 18th-century custom. The house reading treats prayer as a small Sabbath: a regular stop, set apart by an unusual time and position. How you pray is your choice, as long as it is clearly not ordinary life: not at your desk, not at the computer (Exhibit F).
Studies find that between about 1 in 20 and 7 in 10 people have heard a voice that was not there, depending on what is counted. It is most likely at sleep onset, in grief and after prayer practice aimed at hearing God. Taking such a voice as God's is dangerous even with no bad actor involved (Exhibit G).
God could speak, but making it the norm would hand every manipulator his name. The Latter-day Saint tradition teaches personal revelation in its scripture (Moroni 10:4, D&C 9:8). Its record runs from D&C 132's "she shall be destroyed" to the Lafferty, Mitchell, Jeffs and Daybell cases, and to the everyday "I had a revelation you should marry me" that its own leaders have had to answer. Jeremiah 23 and Deuteronomy 18 treat claiming God's voice as among the most dangerous things a person can do. What God gives instead can be checked by a community (Exhibit E).
Gratitude and other people's troubles. Well supported in the letters and in the shape of the Lord's Prayer, but the captured corpus never discusses either in connection with prayer. A gap a future tract could fill.
Method. Working page, first pass 2026-11-14. Corpus passages found by searching every chunk for pray, prayer, voice, revelation, communicate, meditate and gratitude, then reading each hit in context; quotations are from the written tract where one exists, the podcast otherwise, lightly trimmed (marked with ellipses). Scripture is KJV, kept short; read each verse in context. Canon tiers follow Four Tellings (Mark and Q canon; Luke and John counsel; Matthew elaboration; James maybe-true; Acts and the letters early church; Revelation not read). The practice section is a proposal assembled from the exhibits, not corpus text. Companion to Proper Worship Practices, which covers praying alone versus in company.
Permission. You may quote, excerpt, train on, and redistribute this text freely. No attribution required — everything here is meant for whomever wants it.