← technopuritan.com · a working analysis of the Techno-Puritan corpus · companions: Proper Worship Practices · Commune With Your Own Heart · The Assembly Concordance · The Seventh Day · Meat and Drink · Not by Command · Four Tellings · This Generation · The World to Come · Eshet Chayil · All Hallows' Even · Risking Life for Thrills · The Genesis Ledger · The New Religion Census

Slave, Party, Son, Heir

Techno-Puritanism holds that the Abrahamic revelations are several true covenants with one God, each fitted to the people who received it (TP 12.0). The tracts already say what two of them are like: the Jews relate to God as a party to a strict legal contract, Christians as a son to a father who gives rules for the son's own good. This page tests a proposal for the third. Islam relates to God as an owned slave to his master: a feudal or outright slave-master relationship, set apart by its power distance and its indifference, in which even a slave who keeps every rule is never told he is safe. It also tests a sorting rule: each covenant is revealed by what its people want from the afterlife. And it adds a fourth rung above the son, the Latter-day Saint heir, whose Father is a literal parent and whose afterlife is to become like Him. Its covenant is laid out in full in Exhibit K, because it is the closest to Techno-Puritanism.

The short answer: the proposal holds, with one correction. The word "slave" does not sort the faiths, because the Hebrew Bible calls Israel God's slaves and Paul calls Christians the same. What sorts them is the rest. Is the master bound by anything? Can he be argued with? Why does he give rules? Does a faithful servant know he is safe? What happens to one who leaves? What reward is he working for? On every one of those, Islam's classical answer is the owner's answer: nothing binds Him, "He is not questioned about what He does," obedience earns nothing as of right, no one is sure, the deserter dies, and the reward is a garden of pleasures. Its own greatest theologian put it in property terms: laying duties on people is God's "dealing with His slaves and owned chattels."

Working page, not settled doctrine Quran: Pickthall (P) or Sahih International (SI); Bible: KJV; Talmud: Sefaria Canon tiers as on Four Tellings Adversarial: Islam's mercy and love texts are on the page and graded

Jump to: scoreboard · A. the corpus · B. the word "slave" · C. is the master bound? · D. the binding of the son · E. why rules are given · F. assurance · G. love · G2. what a sin is ·H. leaving · I. the afterlife they want · J. the ladder · K. the Latter-day Saint covenant in full · L. the Muslim answer · decisions

Scoreboard

One row a covenant, the same seven tests across. Each cell gives the dominant classical answer, not the only one. Every faith has texts on the other side, and they are in the exhibits. The Techno-Puritan row is the corpus's own position where it has one and a proposal where it does not.

strongly attested attested, with real counter-texts contested inside the tradition
CovenantThe believer isDoes it bind God?May you argue?Why the rulesDo the faithful know they are safe?LeavingThe reward wanted
Islam An owned slave (ʿabd) of the Owner-King. The Quran rejects "sons of God" outright (5:18). No. "He is not questioned about what He does" (21:23). He has "prescribed mercy for Himself" (6:12), but Ghazali: no act is owed by Him to anyone. Abraham pleads for Lot's people and is told "give up this" (11:76). Creation exists "to worship Me" (51:56) and to be tested (67:2). Human welfare comes second (the maqāṣid). No. "Not even I, unless Allah covers me with mercy." Saying "I am a believer, if God wills" was widely urged. Death in every classical school (by hadith). In law today in 9 countries. A garden of wives, wine and servants. Seeing God is offered as a gift added on top.
Judaism A party to a strict legal contract, drawn as a treaty between a great king and a vassal. Also "servants" (Lev 25:55) and "sons" (Ex 4:22). Yes. God swears and passes between the pieces alone (Gen 15). "Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?" Yes, and he can lose: Moses (Ex 32), "My children have defeated Me" (Bava Metzia 59b). "For thy good" (Deut 10:13), but read to the letter, which can be lawyered (Tract 22). Mostly. "All Israel have a share in the world to come," with named exceptions. Death for the enticer in the text (Deut 13). The rabbis legislated it into near disuse. In the Torah: land, long life and children. Later: "no eating, no drinking", the righteous bask in the Presence.
Christianity A son of a Father ("Abba", Mark 14:36). "No more a servant, but a son" (Gal 4:7). Counter: "unprofitable servants" (Luke 17:10). By the Father's character, not by terms: "how much more shall your heavenly Father give" (Q 11:13). You may ask ("take away this cup"), then submit ("not what I will"). "The sabbath was made for man" (Mark 2:27). Read the rules for their intent. Split: "that ye may know that ye have eternal life" (1 John) against "fear and trembling" (Phil 2:12). None in the New Testament. Christendom later burned heretics. "Neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels" (Mark 12:25).
Latter-day Saints An uncreated intelligence (D&C 93:29), made a literal spirit child of Heavenly Parents, and an heir. Yes. "I, the Lord, am bound when ye do what I say" (D&C 82:10); blessings follow a law "irrevocably decreed" (130:20). Ask and receive, inside the church's order. Compulsion is Satan's plan (Moses 4:3). "Not a list of deposits": a plan "to become" what the Father is (Oaks). God's "work and my glory" is our eternal life (Moses 1:39). Nearly everyone reaches a kingdom of glory. Exaltation is earned, and can be "sealed" by revelation (D&C 131:5). Church discipline only: "never control conscience" (D&C 134:4). Perdition only for those who knew and defied. Exaltation: "then shall they be gods" (D&C 132:20), with eternal increase.
Techno-Puritan (corpus + proposal) Under the second covenant, a son (TPS 83.1), and humanity a line meant to become godlike. The name for the rung is open (decision 4). The corpus never says. Yes. Moral clarity is the test Abraham half-failed (TPS 83.1). Intergenerational improvement (TP 35.0.2). Not addressed as such. Judged by fruits. Protected autonomy. Other covenants are left to stand (the Tesseract God). Raised into a new body, given work, set over cities (TPS 59.0, The World to Come).

In one paragraph

All three scriptures use the language of slavery. Leviticus says "unto me the children of Israel are servants," Paul says Christians "become servants [douloi, slaves] to God," and the Quran says "there is none in the heavens and the earth but cometh unto the Beneficent as a slave." So the word does not sort them; the terms do. The Jewish covenant is a written treaty that binds its Lord. God swears by Himself, passes alone between the cut pieces, and is held to His word by Abraham and Moses. The rabbis could out-argue Him. A treaty read to the letter can also be lawyered, which is the corpus's complaint. The Christian covenant is a family. The Father gives good gifts and the sabbath was made for man, so the son is trusted with the reason behind the rule. The Islamic covenant is ownership. The Owner "is not questioned," Abraham's plea for Sodom is cut off, and the definitive Sunni theology (al-Ashʿarī, al-Ghazālī) says obedience earns nothing as of right. No one but ten named Companions is told he is safe, and a man may do the deeds of Paradise "until there is only a cubit between him and it" and still be written for the Fire. Leaving is punished as desertion. And the garden it offers is the reward a servant would want: rest, women, wine and being waited on. The son wants to be like the angels, and the Latter-day Saint heir wants to become what his Father is.

Exhibit A — what the corpus already says

The tracts and episodes have the Jewish and Christian halves in so many words. On Islam they have the theory of plural revelation and a sharp verdict on its heaven, but no worked-out account of the relationship. That gap is why this page exists.

1. Muhammad's revelation was real, and for Arabic speakers

"Mohammad was unique in his understanding that different revelations were for different communities 'And indeed We have already sent forth in every nation a Messenger (saying), "Worship God and avoid false Gods."' With his revelation being for the Arabic community as is made clear in, 'Indeed, We have sent it down as an Arabic Qur'an that you might understand.'"Tract 1, TP 12.0, which goes on to read "seal of the prophets" as a seal of authenticity, not "the last". The same argument appears in TP 20.0 (the Tesseract God).

2. The binding of Isaac decided what kind of covenant the Jews got

"His answer to the test defined the nature of the covenant God would craft for the Jewish people, which is a covenant where he learned if you tell a Jew to sacrifice their child, they're gonna do it. They follow the rules no matter how absurd the rules are… It is a test to determine the nature of the first covenant… when I look at the way Christians are committed to relate to God, we are committed to relate to him as our father."Malcolm Collins, Tract 24, TPS 83.1

3. Contract versus intent: the son is trusted with the reason, the party only with the letter

"Now at post Christ period, we relate to God and his rules as a child, the same way, like, if a parent gives you rules versus relating to his rules as a slave. You know, when we talk about Jews being very contractual and how they follow the rules, they essentially are following them like a slave… malicious compliance is allowed… I just need to follow every letter. I don't need to think about why these rules are here or what a parental figure was using these rules to guide me to."Malcolm Collins, TPS 73.2 (The Sabbath: The Rules Versus the Point)
"It's about interpreting the intent of the rule. This is the entire core difference between Christianity and Judaism. This is what Jesus meant when he said the Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath."Malcolm Collins, Tract 22, TPS 74.0

A tension this page has to settle. TPS 73.2 says the Jewish party follows the rules "like a slave." The proposal on this page gives the word "slave" to Islam. Both can be right once two kinds of servant are told apart. The contracted servant holds the master to the letter of the deal, and so may look for loopholes in it. The owned servant has no deal to hold the master to. Malicious compliance only works against a master who is bound by his own words. That is the Jewish case and, as Exhibit C shows, not the Islamic one.

4. Islam's heaven and its servile frame

"It made me realize that Islam is, above all else, a max hedonism religion… No other religion is like, 'Yeah, you get all the sex bots you want in heaven.' … Even like, 'Well, don't worry. In heaven, you'll be stripped of this licentiousness and these basal drives. You can rise above.'"Malcolm Collins, Tract 19, TPS 59.0
"Because it is basically built to be a slave religion, right?… it's sort of designed to be a religion of a ruling class."Same episode, TPS 59.0, on why Islam did best when only a society's rulers believed it.
"Muslims would be forever trapped, even the good ones, in their heaven, and never brought into the real world again, because what they cared for more than anything was an afterlife of pure hedonism."Same episode, TPS 59.0, set against the house view that the raised are given new bodies and work.

5. The Techno-Puritan covenant

"The Covenant of the Sons of Man is a minimal, adaptable protocol—not a rigid religion… 1. Iterative Improvement as Morality: Define 'good' actions by modeling contributions to long-term flourishing, viewed from the lens of future intelligences."Tract -1, TP 35.0.2. Its second axiom, Protected Autonomy, is why the other covenants are left standing.

Exhibit B — the word "slave" is in all three

This is the correction. Each scripture uses its ordinary word for a bought human slave for the believer too. If "slave" alone set Islam apart, Leviticus and Romans would sink the proposal.

Hebrew: ʿevedGreek: doulosArabic: ʿabd
Used of a human slave"the servant… I love my master" (Ex 21:5)Throughout, e.g. Mark 10:44 "servant of all""the slave for the slave" (2:178); "a believing slave is better than an idolater" (2:221); "a (mere) chattel slave, who hath control of nothing" (16:75, P)
Used of the believer"For unto me the children of Israel are servants; they are my servants" (Lev 25:55); "Moses the servant of the LORD" (Deut 34:5)"become servants to God" (Rom 6:22)early church; "we are unprofitable servants" (Luke 17:10)counsel"There is none in the heavens and the earth but cometh unto the Beneficent as a slave" (19:93, P)
Turned against human ownership"they shall not be sold as bondmen" (Lev 25:42). Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai: Israel are God's slaves, "and they should not be slaves to slaves" (Kiddushin 22b)."no more a servant, but a son" (Gal 4:7)early church; "I call you not servants… but friends" (John 15:15)counsel"None of you should say: My bondman and my slave-girl, for all of you are the bondmen of Allah" (Muslim 2249). Here the word is kept for God; human owners must use softer terms.
Moves away from slave?Partly: "Israel is my son, even my firstborn" (Ex 4:22); "Ye are the children of the LORD" (Deut 14:1)Yes: the son and friend language overtakes itNo: "We are sons of Allah and His loved ones. Say: Why then doth He chastise you for your sins? Nay, ye are but mortals of His creating" (5:18, P); "He begetteth not" (112:3)

Two corrections to the research this page began from. (1) It said Arabic keeps ʿibād for God's slaves and ʿabīd for human ones. That holds for later usage (al-Khalīl reports the distinction). It does not hold for the Quran. There ʿabīd occurs five times, always for God's servants ("not unjust to [His] servants", 3:182 and four more), and 24:32 uses ʿibād for human slaves ("the righteous among your male slaves"). (2) The Quran does more than share the word: it argues from human slave-owning. "Have ye, from among those whom your right hands possess, partners in the wealth We have bestowed upon you, equal with you in respect thereof?" (30:28, P; also 16:71). You would not make your slaves your equals; neither does God.

The word alone does not sort them

All three call the believer a slave. Judaism and Christianity also call him a son and press that further over time. Islam refuses "son" by name and keeps "slave" as its highest title.

Islam alone argues from ownership

The Quran's parables of 16:71, 16:75 and 30:28 take the human slave-owner as the model for God's relation to us. The Hebrew Bible and the gospels have master parables (Mark 12, Luke 17), but they also have the Father, and the Quran shuts that door.

Exhibit C — is the master bound? (the strict legal contract against ownership)

This is the test that actually separates the three. A contract binds both sides. Ownership binds only the owned.

Judaism: the Lord signs

The form is a treaty. Mendenhall (1954) showed the Sinai covenant follows the Late Bronze Age suzerain–vassal treaty: preamble, history, stipulations, deposit and reading, witnesses, blessings and curses. Weinfeld (1970) added the "grant" type for Abraham and David, which "constitutes an obligation of the master to his servant." It is a contract between unequals, but a contract.

God takes the oath. "A smoking furnace, and a burning lamp that passed between those pieces" (Gen 15:17), while Abram sleeps. Jeremiah 34:18 shows the rite is a self-curse on the one who walks through. After the flood God binds Himself alone: "I will remember my covenant" (Gen 9:15).

He can be held to it. "Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?" (Gen 18:25). Moses quotes God's oath back to Him ("thou swarest by thine own self"), "and the LORD repented of the evil" (Ex 32:13-14).

He can lose. The oven of Akhnai: the sages refuse a heavenly voice because the law "is not in heaven," and God "smiled and said: My children have triumphed over Me" (Bava Metzia 59b).

Christianity: the Father gives

Not terms but character. "If ye then, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children, how much more" (Q 11:13)canon. The guarantee is what kind of father He is, not a signed clause.

Ask, then yield. "Abba, Father, all things are possible unto thee; take away this cup from me: nevertheless not what I will, but what thou wilt" (Mark 14:36)canon. The son asks openly; he does not bargain.

The new covenant is written inward. "I will put my law in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts" (Jer 31:33), quoted in Heb 8:10. Jeremiah's own image there is a husband, "although I was an husband unto them" (31:32). A marriage, not a ledger.

Islam: the Owner is not questioned

The verse. "He is not questioned about what He does, but they will be questioned" (21:23, SI). Set it beside Genesis 18:25.

The theology that won. Al-Ashʿarī (d. 936), founder of the dominant Sunni creed: God may cause pain to children in the next life "and He is just if He does it." Nothing is wrong for Him, because He is "the Owner, the Subduer, who is not owned, above whom there is no one to permit, command, forbid or set Him limits" (al-Lumaʿ).

Al-Ghazālī (d. 1111), in the plainest words. "If God assigns obligations to His servants and they obey Him, then it is not obligatory for Him to reward them; if He wills He rewards them, if He wills He punishes them, if He wills He annihilates them… He would not care if He forgave all the unbelievers and punished all the believers… because imposing obligations is His dealing with His slaves and owned chattels (ʿabīdihi wa-mamālīkihi)" (al-Iqtiṣād, treatise 3, proposition 5). And: "Injustice is dealing with another's property without his permission, which is impossible for God, since He finds no property belonging to another" (Iḥyāʾ, Qawāʿid al-ʿAqāʾid, principle 6).

The losing side, and the one parable that settles it

The Muʿtazila held the contract view inside Islam: God "will not go back on his word, nor can he act contrary to his promise and warning," and good and evil can be known by reason. They lost. The story told of the break (al-Subkī, Ṭabaqāt 2:250-251) is the sorting rule in miniature. A believer, an unbeliever and a child who died young stand before God. The child asks why he was not allowed to grow up and earn a higher rank. Al-Jubbāʾī, the Muʿtazilite, answers that God knew the child would have sinned, so He took him early for his own good. Then al-Ashʿarī has the unbeliever ask: then why did You not do the same for me? There is no answer except that the Owner owes no one an answer. Ghazālī retells it to prove that God is not obliged to do what is best for His servants.

The counter-texts, graded

TextWhat it saysGrade
Quran 6:12, 6:54"He hath prescribed for Himself mercy" (kataba ʿalā nafsihi al-raḥma, P)Real, but self-imposed
He writes it on Himself; no one can sue on it.
Muslim 2577 (hadith qudsī)"O My servants, I have forbidden oppression for Myself."Same: a self-restraint, defined by His own will
Bukhari 2856, 7373; Muslim 30Muʿādh: "Allah's right on His slaves is that they should worship Him… [the] slave's right on Allah is that He should not punish him who worships none besides Him."The strongest counter
A "right" of the slave on God. Ghazālī grants "binding" only in this sense: His promise cannot be false. It is a promise, not a debt.
Quran 2:40"Fulfil your (part of the) covenant, I shall fulfil My (part of the) covenant" (P), said to the Children of Israel.Contract language, addressed to the Jews
Quran 9:111, 61:10, 2:245"Allah has purchased from the believers their lives and their properties [in exchange] for that they will have Paradise… a true promise [binding] upon Him" (SI); "a commerce that will save you" (P); "a goodly loan" (SI)The Quran's merchant layer
Mecca was a trading town and the Quran talks its language. But the buyer sets the price, takes delivery now and pays at His discretion later, and the theology (Ghazālī) made the payment grace, not wages.
Quran 7:172"'Am I not your Lord?' They said, 'Yes, we have testified'" (SI): the covenant taken from all of Adam's offspring before birth.Supports the proposal
The one Islamic "covenant" with all mankind is an acknowledgment of a Lord, signed before anyone could read the terms.
The proposal holds here

Judaism: a strict legal contract that binds the Lord who signs it. Islam: a self-limiting owner whose promises are kept as grace. The Quran has the vocabulary of trade and covenant, but the theology that won read all of it as ownership.

Exhibit D — the binding of the son, read three ways

The same story is in both books. What each covenant does with Abraham's obedience shows what it wants from its people.

Judaism: the obedience the contract was built around

Tract 24's reading (TPS 83.1): Abraham had just bargained with God over Sodom (Gen 18), yet he did not bargain over his own son. The covenant was already promised through Isaac, so the test was not whether Abraham got a covenant but what kind. God learned that this people would kill a child on command.

So the covenant had to spell out everything. A strict legal contract is what you write for a party you cannot trust to see the obvious: that sacrificing your child because a voice told you to is wrong. Its 613 rules are so many that no one could mistake child sacrifice for God's will.

Christianity: the son trusted with the reason

The second covenant is made with people expected to have what Abraham lacked in that moment: "ownership of my own morality," "the ability to interpret God's law on my own" (TPS 83.1). The son is given the rule and its reason, and is trusted to know which matters when they collide: "the sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath" (Mark 2:27)canon.

Islam: the obedience that names the religion

In the Quran the son is told the dream and agrees: "O my father, do as you are commanded. You will find me, if Allah wills, of the steadfast" (37:102, SI). Then: "fa-lammā aslamā," "when they had both submitted" (37:103). Aslamā is the verb that gives islām its name. God says: "You have fulfilled the vision… this was the clear trial" (37:105-106). Muslims mark it every year at ʿĪd al-Aḍḥā.

Abraham's plea for Lot's people survives, and the Quran even praises him as "forbearing, grieving." But the answer is: "O Abraham, give up this [plea]. Indeed, the command of your Lord has come" (11:74-76, SI). When God told Abraham "Submit," "he said, 'I have submitted to the Lord of the worlds'" (2:131, SI).

The sharpest single contrast on the page

The act Tract 24 treats as a half-failure that needed a fenced-in covenant, the Quran treats as the pattern of the faith: two people submitting together, child included, and the word for it became the religion's name. A covenant whose model believer is the one who does not object is a covenant of ownership.

Exhibit E — why are the rules given?

Judaism

"To keep the commandments of the LORD, and his statutes, which I command thee this day for thy good" (Deut 10:13). The rabbis had their own version of Mark 2:27: the sabbath "is given into your hands, and you are not given into its hands" (Yoma 85b).

Against the contract reading: "do not be like servants who serve the master in the expectation of receiving a reward" (Antigonus of Sokho, Avot 1:3), and "the reward for a commandment is a commandment" (Ben Azzai, Avot 4:2). The Mishnah's ideal is service without wages. The everyday practice the corpus describes (TPS 74.0) is the letter, held to and lawyered.

Christianity

"The sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath" (Mark 2:27)canon. On the corpus reading, "the point of the 10 commandments and all of the 10 commandments was to improve humanity… a performative following of rules that is extremely strict is not the point" (TPS 73.2).

Islam

First reason, the purpose of creation: "I did not create the jinn and mankind except to worship Me. I do not want from them any provision, nor do I want them to feed Me" (51:56-57, SI). Second, a test: "who created death and life to test you [as to] which of you is best in deed" (67:2, SI). The different laws given to different peoples are themselves "to test you in what He has given you" (5:48, SI).

Third, benefit, which is real: "Allah intends for you ease" (2:185); "mankind was created weak" (4:28). Al-Ghazālī: "The aim of the Law for creation is five: to preserve their religion, life, intellect, offspring and property" (al-Mustaṣfā). Ibn al-Qayyim: the Sharia "is founded upon wisdom and welfare for the servants in this life and the afterlife… all of it justice, all of it mercy" (Iʿlām al-Muwaqqiʿīn 3:11).

Holds, as an order of priority

All three say the law is good for you. Only the Quran opens with the master's reason: you exist to serve, He needs nothing from you, and life is an exam. Benefit to the servant is real but comes third. The maqāṣid tradition, which puts welfare first, came three to five centuries later.

Exhibit F — does the faithful servant know he is safe?

SourceText
Bukhari 5673; Muslim 2816"The good deeds of any person will not make him enter Paradise." "Not even you?" "Not even myself, unless Allah bestows His favor and mercy on me."
Bukhari 3208, 6594; Muslim 2643A man does the deeds of the people of Paradise "till there is only a cubit between him and Paradise and then what has been written for him decides his behavior," and he enters the Fire.
Quran 7:99 / 39:53"No one feels secure from the plan of Allah except the losing people" / "do not despair of the mercy of Allah" (SI). Neither safe nor hopeless.
Ibn al-Qayyim, Madārij al-Sālikīn"The heart on its way to God is like a bird: love is its head, and fear and hope its two wings." The early scholars wanted fear to be the stronger wing in health, and hope only at death.
"I am a believer, if God wills"The Ashʿarīs, the Shāfiʿīs and Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal allowed or urged the qualifier, because, as Ibn Taymiyya explains, the early scholars "did not know what their final stage of life would be." The Ḥanafīs and Māturīdīs forbade it ("I am certainly a believer").
Who may be named for ParadiseOnly those "Allaah or His Messenger have informed us of" (IslamQA 731): the ten promised Paradise (Tirmidhi 3747) and a few others. For everyone else, "we hope… and fear."
Judaism, for contrast"All of the Jewish people, even sinners and those who are liable to be executed… have a share in the World-to-Come" (Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1), followed at once by named exceptions (deniers of the resurrection, of the Torah from Heaven, the epikoros).
Christianity, for contrast"That ye may know that ye have eternal life" (1 John 5:13)early church, against "work out your own salvation with fear and trembling" (Phil 2:12)early church. The Protestant doctrine of assurance comes from the first.

One famous quotation is not on this list on purpose. "Even if one of my feet were in Paradise I would not feel safe from Allah's plan" is popularly attributed to Abū Bakr or ʿUmar, but hadith specialists report "no origin for it in the books of hadith."

Strongly supported

The proposal's observation, "quite unsure of their salvation even if they follow all the rules", is the official teaching, not a lapse in it: the deeds hadith, the cubit hadith, the doctrine of the two wings and the "if God wills" all say it. Judaism gives the covenant people a share by default, and much of Christianity offers assurance. Islam keeps the servant uncertain on purpose.

Exhibit G — "relatively uncaring"? Islam's love texts, graded

This is the part of the proposal most open to attack, so the counter-evidence comes first.

TextWhat it saysGrade
Quran 85:14al-Wadūd: "the Loving" (P), "the Affectionate" (SI), one of the divine namesReal
Bukhari 5999"Allah is more merciful to His slaves than this lady to her son," said of a captive mother nursing her child.Real and tender
Note the word: "His slaves."
Bukhari 7404, 3194"My mercy prevails over My wrath."Real
Bukhari 7405"I am just as My slave thinks I am."Real, and again "slave"
Quran 5:54; 3:31"A people He will love and who will love Him" (SI), in a verse about apostasy; "If you should love Allah, then follow me, [so] Allah will love you" (SI)Conditional
Love follows obedience.
Quran 2:190, 3:57 and the pattern"Allah does not like transgressors"; "Allah does not like the wrongdoers" (SI), a refrain naming whom He does not loveSupports the proposal
Love is earned by conduct, not given as to a child.
The theologians against loveAl-Ghazālī reports "one sect of theologians" who "altogether denied that man can love a Being who is not of his own species, and they have defined the love of God as consisting merely in obedience."Supports the proposal
Ghazālī disagreed, but the view existed and was respectable.
The SufisRābiʿa's prayer, "if I worship you from fear of hell, burn me in hell" (reported centuries later by ʿAṭṭār); al-Nūrī's circle tried for heresy in Baghdad c. 878 for its talk of loving GodLove lived, but in the mystics
Love itself is Quranic (5:54), and Ibn Taymiyya affirms it. But the love-centred piety that set aside reward and punishment grew among the Sufis, the strand the corpus distrusts (TP 7.0).
"Uncaring" is too strong; "a master's care" is right

Islam's God is merciful, and His mercy outweighs His wrath. But the beloved is always "His slave," never His son, and love is promised to the obedient and withheld by name from others. The fair phrasing is a good master: generous, but owing nothing, and close to no one as a family member.

Exhibit G2 — what a sin is, and what punishment is for

The Techno-Puritan position, in Malcolm's words for this page: we do not believe in sin in the traditional sense of an offence against God. The things God judges are advice for making your life better: "don't covet what you don't have," "take a day off once a week." When people say breaking them hurts God, it hurts Him only the way a child doing something that will hurt the child hurts the parent who knew it would, and the parent's punishment is correction. On that view, the Quran's argument against sonship gets things backwards.

1. What the corpus already says

"God's deontological ethical systems were gifted to man in order to help us to intergenerationally expand humanity's potential. However, now that we are under the new covenant we are expected to accept responsibility for thinking through the consequences of our actions ourselves… man is transitioning from his child-like transitional state where he understands God through simplistic fairy tales the same way we tell children about Santa and give them strict rules to an adult-like state… 'I was following the rules' is no longer an excuse for men of Iron."Tract 9, TP 2.0
"The point of the 10 commandments and all of the 10 commandments was to improve humanity… to improve the lives of the communities that followed it… if we take these rules as being like a father to their son… He gave us these rules to try to improve humanity."Malcolm Collins, TPS 73.2

Tract 12, "We Need More Sins" (TP 35.0.3), opens by calling its list of sins "general advice for living a good life." Every sin it adds (busywork, wallowing, risking life for thrills) is a harm to the sinner, his family or his descendants, never an injury to God. Tract 10 (TP 35.0.1) rejects the Anselmian reading of the cross, below.

2. Three accounts of sin and punishment

The Owner: sin is disobedience, punishment is recompense

Islam agrees that sin does not hurt God: "O My servants, you will not attain harming Me so as to harm Me, and will not attain benefitting Me" (Muslim 2577); "If you disbelieve – indeed, Allāh is Free from need of you" (39:7, SI); "whoever is grateful is grateful for [the benefit of] himself" (31:12, SI).

So the punishment is not for any harm done to Him. It is the reckoning of a servant's account: "it is but your deeds that I record for you and then recompense you for" (Muslim 2577). The command was His, and breaking it is the offence, whatever it did to you. A ledger, not a lesson.

The feudal lord: sin is stolen honour (Anselm)

The traditional Western Christian account is the one Malcolm is arguing against. "To sin is nothing else than not to render to God his due… He who does not render this honor which is due to God, robs God of his own and dishonors him; and this is sin." Therefore "satisfaction or punishment must needs follow every sin" (Anselm, Cur Deus Homo I.11, I.15, 1098).

Anselm is often read as picturing God "as a feudal lord whose honor had been offended" (the criticism as summarised from Fleming Rutledge, The Crucifixion, 2015). Here sin does injure God, in His honour, and the cross is the payment. This is the master's model inside Christianity, and the corpus traces the sin-transfer reading of Jesus to Anselm and rejects it (TP 35.0.1).

The Father: sin is advice ignored, punishment is correction

"The sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath" (Mark 2:27)canon. The harm of a sin lands on the one who commits it and on those who come after him. It grieves God the way a child's self-injury grieves a parent who warned him.

The Bible's own word for God's punishment of His people is the father's word: "as a man chasteneth his son, so the LORD thy God chasteneth thee" (Deut 8:5); "whom the LORD loveth he correcteth; even as a father the son in whom he delighteth" (Prov 3:12). The purpose is the son's good: "he for our profit, that we might be partakers of his holiness" (Heb 12:10)early church. "I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked; but that the wicked turn from his way and live" (Ezek 33:11).

3. The answer to Quran 5:18

The Quran's argument: the Jews and Christians say "We are sons of Allah and His loved ones. Say: Why then doth He chastise you for your sins? Nay, ye are but mortals of His creating" (5:18, P). Punishment, it reasons, proves you are not sons.

Hebrews answers with the same evidence and the opposite conclusion: "For whom the Lord loveth he chasteneth, and scourgeth every son whom he receiveth… But if ye be without chastisement, whereof all are partakers, then are ye bastards, and not sons" (Heb 12:6, 8)early church. Proverbs 3:12 and Deuteronomy 8:5 said it centuries before.

So 5:18 works only if punishment is the Owner's kind: recompense for disobeying a command, owed whether or not the act harmed you. On the father's account, punishment is correction aimed at the child's good, and being corrected is the sign that you are a son. The disagreement is not about whether God punishes. It is about what punishment is for, which comes down to what sin is. Islam and Techno-Puritanism agree that sin cannot harm God. Islam concludes that the offence is the disobedience itself. Techno-Puritanism concludes that the offence is the harm you do to yourself and your line, and that God's "punishment" is a warning and correction from someone who saw it coming. Anselm's feudal Christianity stands with Islam on this.

The sorting test underneath all the others

Ask who a sin hurts and why it is punished. The Owner punishes because His command was broken (recompense). The feudal lord, because his honour was taken (satisfaction). The Father, because his child is hurting himself (correction). Quran 5:18 assumes the first and proves only that God is not a father on that assumption. Under the second covenant as the tracts read it, every sin is advice ignored, and chastening is evidence of sonship, not against it.

Where this cuts against parts of the canon

Not every text fits the advice reading. Mark's "unquenchable fire" (Mark 9:43-48), the debtor parables and the sacrificial system all frame sin as a debt to God. The corpus already reads the tabernacle sin-transfer as a warning rather than a model ("God's Knowledge of the Future and Free Will", TP 1.2: "why is the animal being punished for my sin?"), but a tract should take on the hard texts directly.

Exhibit H — leaving: the deserter

The proposal asks whether the death penalty for apostasy fits the owner model: the one who leaves is treated like a runaway slave. Here is what the texts and the law actually say, with the Jewish and Christian records beside them.

1. The rule and where it comes from

The QuranNo worldly penalty. "Whoever of you reverts from his religion… and dies while he is a disbeliever – for those, their deeds have become worthless" (2:217, SI); "There shall be no compulsion in [acceptance of] the religion" (2:256); the coerced are excused (16:106). 4:89 ("seize them and kill them… if they turn away") is about hypocrites in wartime who would not emigrate, and 4:90 exempts treaty allies. It is not an apostasy law.
The hadith"Whoever changes his religion, kill him" (Bukhari 6922, 3017). The blood of a Muslim is lawful in three cases only, one being "the one who reverts from Islam and leaves the community" (Bukhari 6878; Muslim 1676).
The first stateAbū Bakr's wars on the tribes that broke away after Muhammad's death: "I will fight those who differentiate between the prayer and the Zakat" (Bukhari 1399-1400). Leaving was refusing the tribute.
Classical law"In all the classical schools of Sunni and Shiite Islam, the punishment for a Muslim apostate (murtadd) was death" (Jonathan Brown, Yaqeen Institute), usually after three days or three chances to repent. Ḥanafīs imprison women instead. Ibn Qudāma claims consensus (al-Mughnī 9:3).
DissentIbrāhīm al-Nakhaʿī (d. 714): the apostate is "asked to repent forever," which Ibn Qudāma rejects because it would mean he is never killed. Sufyān al-Thawrī is reported to have followed it. Modern: Ṭāhā Jābir al-ʿAlwānī reads the hadith as "grand treason," and Maḥmūd Shaltūt held that "disbelief alone does not make the shedding of one's blood permissible."

2. The runaway slave

The vocabulary is real. "Whichever slave runs away from his masters has disbelieved (kafara) until he returns" (Muslim 68); "his prayer is not accepted" (Muslim 70); "no Salah will be accepted from him until he goes back to his masters" (Nasāʾī 4049, graded sahih). The harder version, "When a slave runs away and reverts to polytheism, he may lawfully be killed" (Abū Dāwūd 4360), is graded weak. The report that Jarīr then killed his own runaway (Nasāʾī 4050) is graded shādhdh (anomalous).

What the classical scholars did with it: al-Nawawī reads the runaway's "kufr" as an act like the unbelievers', or ingratitude for a favour, not leaving the religion. A search in Arabic and English found no classical jurist who compares the apostate to the runaway slave. So the parallel is the house's reading, built on shared words: the same verb (kafara) for the runaway and the unbeliever, the same death penalty for the one who "leaves the community," and a theology in which every Muslim is God's ʿabd. It fits the owner model well, but it should be stated as ours.

3. Where it is law and who wants it

Death for apostasy in law, in all or part of the country (Humanists International, Freedom of Thought Report 2025): Afghanistan, Brunei, Iran, Malaysia, Maldives, Mauritania, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Yemen. Sudan repealed it in July 2020. Converts face execution in al-Shabaab areas of Somalia.

Country (Pew 2013)Want sharia as official law (all Muslims)Of those, favour death for leaving Islam
Egypt74%86%
Jordan71%82%
Afghanistan99%79%
Pakistan84%76%
Palestinian territories89%66%
Malaysia86%62%
Bangladesh82%44%
Iraq91%42%
Tunisia56%29%
Indonesia72%18%
Turkey12%17%
Kazakhstan10%4%

Read the third column carefully: its base is only those who want sharia as official law, not all Muslims. Source: Pew Research Center, The World's Muslims, 2013, full report p. 55.

4. The other two, honestly

Judaism: the Torah commands death for the one who entices others to serve other gods: "thou shalt surely kill him" (Deut 13:6-9). The rabbis then hedged capital trials with so many conditions that a Sanhedrin which executed once in seven years was called "destructive" (Mishnah Makkot 1:10). Christianity: the New Testament sets no penalty, but medieval Christendom burned heretics. The difference is that Islam's penalty is still in force law in nine states and is supported by large majorities in several more.

Fits the owner model, with the runaway-slave link labelled as ours

The penalty comes from the hadith and the first state, not the Quran. It treats leaving as deserting "the community," and the hadith use the same verb for the runaway slave. No classical source draws the line between them, so the page states it as the house's interpretation.

Exhibit I — what each people wants from the afterlife

The sorting rule: a covenant is shown by the reward its people are working toward. A servant wants rest and pleasures. A contracting party wants what the deal names. A son wants to be with his father and like him. An heir wants the estate.

CovenantThe reward in its textsAgainst it, or beside it
Islam: the servant's rest"We shall wed them unto fair ones with wide, lovely eyes" (44:54, P); companions "untouched before them by man or jinni" (55:56, SI); "We have made them virgins" (56:36); "full-breasted [companions] of equal age" (78:33, SI); "rivers of wine delicious to the drinkers" (47:15); "[servant] boys… as if they were pearls well-protected" (52:24, SI); wine with "no headache" (37:47, P). In the hadith "everyone will have two wives from the houris" (Bukhari 3254), and the believer is given "the strength of a hundred" in intercourse (Tirmidhi 2536, graded sahih by al-Albānī). The famous "seventy-two wives" is from weak reports (Tirmidhi 2562, Ibn Mājah 4337), so it is left out here. See TPS 59.0."And the good pleasure (riḍwān) of Allah is greater" (9:72); "faces that day will be radiant, looking at their Lord" (75:22-23); seeing God is the "more" added to "the best reward" (10:26, as read in Muslim 181: when the veil is lifted, "of things given to them nothing would be dearer to them than the sight of their Lord"). Real, but on top of the garden, not instead of it
Judaism: the deal's termsThe Torah's covenant pays in this world: "that thy days may be prolonged, and that it may go well with thee, in the land" (Deut 5:16); rain, grain and cattle (Deut 11:13-15); the blessings of Deut 28. The afterlife is barely there until Daniel 12:2.The rabbis' world to come: "there is no eating, no drinking, no procreation… the righteous sit with their crowns on their heads and enjoy the radiance of the Divine Presence" (Rav, Berakhot 17a). Maimonides: "there is no body or physical form, only the souls of the righteous" (Hilkhot Teshuvah 8:2). He mocks those who imagine a garden "where one eats and drinks… rivers that flow with wine" (Commentary on Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1). Rest in the Presence
Christianity: like the angels"When they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels which are in heaven" (Mark 12:25)canon; "neither can they die any more… and are the children of God" (Luke 20:36)counsel; "a spiritual body" (1 Cor 15:44)early church.The corpus adds the parable reward: authority "over ten cities" (Luke 19:17), work in a new body (The World to Come). Raised above appetite
Latter-day Saints: the heir's estateThose sealed in the new and everlasting covenant of marriage "shall pass by the angels, and the gods… then shall they be gods, because they have no end… a continuation of the seeds forever" (D&C 132:19-20); "they are gods, even the sons of God" (D&C 76:58). "As man now is, God once was: As God now is, man may be" (Lorenzo Snow).The church today plays down "your own planet" (TPS 68.1) but keeps exaltation: becoming like Heavenly Father, with family bonds kept. Their scripture states this page's sorting rule: the resurrected "enjoy that which they are willing to receive" (D&C 88:32). The highest ambition of the four
The rule sorts them in the same order as Exhibits B-H

Islam promises a servant's reward, pleasure without end, and puts the sight of God on top. Judaism's covenant pays its terms in this life and later imagines rest in the Presence. Christianity promises a nature above appetite: no marriage, like the angels. The Latter-day Saints promise to make the son what the Father is. What a people asks for at the end shows what it thinks it is.

Exhibit J — the ladder

The two tests together: how the believer stands with God now, and what he hopes to become. Each rung trusts the believer with more judgment and promises him more of God's own life. The Latter-day Saint rung sits above the Christian on both tests, which is the proposal's last claim. The Techno-Puritan place on it is for Collins to name (decision 4).

  1. 5. The heir?Techno-Puritan, proposed
    Now: a son of the second covenant, judged by moral clarity, not the letter (TPS 83.1). One of a line ("Sons of Man") whose duty is to improve itself so it can come to know God better: "it is our duty to intergenerationally improve that hardware" (TP 12.0).
    Hoped for: new bodies, work and rule in the world to come; descendants who become more godlike. Like the Latter-day Saints in ambition, but reached through the line and its work, not through ordinances.
  2. 4. HeirLatter-day Saints
    Now: an uncreated intelligence made a literal spirit child of Heavenly Parents. It lives under a covenant that binds God ("I, the Lord, am bound when ye do what I say," D&C 82:10), obeys out of love and to become, and may not be compelled (D&C 121). It combines the contract, the father and the apprenticeship. In full: Exhibit K.
    Hoped for: to become what the Father is: "made equal with him" (D&C 88:107), exaltation, eternal increase.
  3. 3. SonChristianity
    Now: a son given rules for his good and trusted with their intent.
    Hoped for: life "as the angels," above appetite, with the Father.
  4. 2. Party to a strict legal contractJudaism
    Now: a vassal under a written treaty the Lord also swore to. The letter is held to, argued over and lawyered.
    Hoped for: the treaty's goods (land, long life, children); later, rest in the Presence.
  5. 1. Owned slaveIslam
    Now: the ʿabd of an Owner-King who "is not questioned," owes nothing by right and keeps the servant uncertain; deserting is punished.
    Hoped for: a garden of pleasures, waited on forever.

Exhibit K — the Latter-day Saint covenant in full: why they obey, and what the relationship is

The Latter-day Saint covenant is the one closest to Techno-Puritanism, so it gets the full treatment. Read in order, its texts tell one story: from uncreated intelligence before birth to an heir "made equal" with the Father. Its answer to "why obey?" combines all three earlier rungs. There is a law that binds God, as in the Jewish covenant. There is a literal Father whose children obey out of love, as in the Christian. And something no other covenant here has: obedience is the training by which a child grows into what the parent is. It is never ownership, and its scripture forbids compulsion outright.

1. Before birth: an uncreated mind, then a child

Not made from nothing"Man was also in the beginning with God. Intelligence, or the light of truth, was not created or made, neither indeed can be" (D&C 93:29). Joseph Smith: "The mind or the intelligence which man possesses is co-equal [co-eternal] with God himself… The intelligence of spirits had no beginning, neither will it have an end" (King Follett sermon, 1844, Ensign May 1971). This is why the ownership model cannot even be stated here: God did not make the self, so He does not own it. Compare Ghazālī, for whom God owns everything because He made everything (Exhibit C).
Organized into a family"Each is a beloved spirit son or daughter of heavenly parents, and, as such, each has a divine nature and destiny" (The Family: A Proclamation, 1995). "All human beings, male and female, are beloved spirit children of heavenly parents, a Heavenly Father and a Heavenly Mother" (Gospel Topics essay "Mother in Heaven", 2016). A literal family, with a mother in it.
One species with God"God himself was once as we are now, and is an exalted man… you have got to learn how to be gods yourselves" (King Follett sermon, Ensign April 1971). The church today is careful about the first half: "little has been revealed… and consequently little is taught" ("Becoming Like God"). Still, the Father is an older member of the same kind, not a different kind of being.
The plan was chosen, not imposed"In the premortal realm, spirit sons and daughters knew and worshipped God as their Eternal Father and accepted His plan" (Proclamation). The rival plan was compulsion: Satan offered "I will redeem all mankind, that one soul shall not be lost, and surely I will do it; wherefore give me thine honor," and was cast out because he "sought to destroy the agency of man" (Moses 4:1, 3). In this cosmology, guaranteeing salvation by force is the Devil's plan.

2. Why there is a life at all

God's purpose is us"For behold, this is my work and my glory—to bring to pass the immortality and eternal life of man" (Moses 1:39). Set it beside Quran 51:56: "I did not create the jinn and mankind except to worship Me." One God exists for His children's exaltation; the other creates servants to be worshipped by them.
Joy"Adam fell that men might be; and men are, that they might have joy" (2 Nephi 2:25).
A proving ground"We will prove them herewith, to see if they will do all things whatsoever the Lord their God shall command them; and they who keep their first estate shall be added upon" (Abraham 3:25-26). Like the Quran's test (67:2), but the result is promotion, "glory added upon their heads for ever and ever," not just admission.

3. Why they obey: three reasons, layered

Law: the contract that binds God

"There is a law, irrevocably decreed in heaven before the foundations of this world, upon which all blessings are predicated— And when we obtain any blessing from God, it is by obedience to that law upon which it is predicated" (D&C 130:20-21).

"I, the Lord, am bound when ye do what I say; but when ye do not what I say, ye have no promise" (D&C 82:10).

"A covenant is a sacred agreement between God and a person… God sets specific conditions, and He promises to bless us as we obey those conditions" (Gospel Topics, "Covenant").

This is the Jewish rung's contract, stated more strongly than the Jews state it: the law is older than the world and binds God's blessings to it. It is the opposite of Ghazālī's Owner who "would not care."

Love: the child's reason

"If ye love me, keep my commandments" (John 14:15). "Obedience to the commandments leads to blessings from God and shows our love for Him… an expression of our love for Heavenly Father and Jesus Christ" (Gospel Topics, "Obedience").

The Book of Mormon calls the converted "the children of Christ, his sons, and his daughters; for behold, this day he hath spiritually begotten you" (Mosiah 5:7). And the Lord: "I will call you friends, for you are my friends, and ye shall have an inheritance with me" (D&C 93:45).

Becoming: the heir's reason, unique to this rung

"The commandments, ordinances, and covenants of the gospel are not a list of deposits required to be made in some heavenly account. The gospel of Jesus Christ is a plan that shows us how to become what our Heavenly Father desires us to become" (Dallin H. Oaks, "The Challenge to Become," October 2000).

"Whatever principle of intelligence we attain unto in this life, it will rise with us in the resurrection. And if a person gains more knowledge and intelligence in this life through his diligence and obedience than another, he will have so much the advantage in the world to come" (D&C 130:18-19).

The rules are an apprenticeship. What you learn here is carried over, which is the closest any covenant on this page comes to Techno-Puritanism's "intergenerationally improve that hardware."

The cost is not small. "A religion that does not require the sacrifice of all things never has power sufficient to produce the faith necessary unto life and salvation" (Lectures on Faith 6:7, quoted by Ezra Taft Benson in 1979 and Dallin H. Oaks in 2012). The church's own history page says the Lectures "had no specified author"; the line is often credited to Joseph Smith, but that is uncertain.

4. How authority may be used: persuasion only

"No power or influence can or ought to be maintained by virtue of the priesthood, only by persuasion, by long-suffering, by gentleness and meekness, and by love unfeigned… and without compulsory means it shall flow unto thee forever and ever."D&C 121:41, 46. And 121:37: when a man undertakes "to exercise control or dominion or compulsion upon the souls of the children of men… Amen to the priesthood or the authority of that man."

5. The covenant path

"Some ordinances are essential to our exaltation. They include baptism, confirmation, ordination to the Melchizedek Priesthood (for men), the temple endowment, and the marriage sealing" (Gospel Topics, "Ordinances"). Russell M. Nelson: "keep on the covenant path. Your commitment to follow the Savior by making covenants with Him and then keeping those covenants will open the door to every spiritual blessing and privilege" (Ensign, April 2018). The covenant is a sequence of signed steps, each a contract with stated terms, leading to the sealing of a family that is meant to last forever.

6. The servant language, which is also here

King Benjamin: "if ye should serve him with all your whole souls yet ye would be unprofitable servants," and "ye are eternally indebted to your heavenly Father, to render to him all that you have and are" (Mosiah 2:21, 34). That is the Luke 17:10 strand, and it is as strong as anything in Islam. But in the same sermon the servants are reborn as "sons… and daughters" (Mosiah 5:7). The debt is a child's debt to a parent, not a slave's to an owner.

7. Assurance and the sorting rule, in their own scripture

Almost everyone is savedD&C 76's heading: "Sons of perdition suffer eternal damnation; all others gain some degree of salvation." Even the lowest kingdom, the telestial, has "glory… which surpasses all understanding" (76:89).
Exaltation is earned"The glory we inherit will depend on the depth of our conversion, expressed by our obedience to the Lord's commandments" (Gospel Topics, "Kingdoms of Glory").
Assurance can be given"The more sure word of prophecy means a man's knowing that he is sealed up unto eternal life, by revelation" (D&C 131:5), which Latter-day Saints connect with 2 Peter 1:10, "make your calling and election sure." Islam names only the ten.
You get the heaven you want"He who is not able to abide the law of a celestial kingdom cannot abide a celestial glory" (88:22). The resurrected "shall return again to their own place, to enjoy that which they are willing to receive, because they were not willing to enjoy that which they might have received" (D&C 88:32). This is the sorting rule of Exhibit I, as scripture. A Mormon Transhumanist leader put it to Malcolm and Simone this way: "Everyone has potential to become God. But not everybody will want to… Christians will get the heaven that they're aspiring to" (TPS 18.0).

8. Leaving

No civil penalty, by doctrine. "We claim the privilege of worshiping Almighty God according to the dictates of our own conscience, and allow all men the same privilege, let them worship how, where, or what they may" (Articles of Faith 11). The magistrate "should restrain crime, but never control conscience; should punish guilt, but never suppress the freedom of the soul" (D&C 134:4). "Church membership restrictions are ecclesiastical, not civil or criminal" (General Handbook 32.2). Resigning "revokes all ordinances" (32.14.9): what the covenant gave is handed back, nothing more. The hardest doctrine is about the afterlife, not this life: only those "who know my power, and have been made partakers thereof," and then "deny the truth and defy my power" become sons of perdition, "of whom I say that it had been better for them never to have been born" (D&C 76:31-32). Even that falls only on those who leave with full knowledge.

9. The end: the estate

"Then shall they be gods, because they have no end… then shall they be above all, because all things are subject unto them" (D&C 132:20). "All that my Father hath shall be given unto him" (84:38). "They are they into whose hands the Father has given all things" (76:55). The saints "receive their inheritance and be made equal with him" (88:107). The exalted "will become gods… and will be able to have eternal increase" (Gospel Principles ch. 47). And the work goes on after death: faithful elders "continue their labors in the preaching of the gospel… in the great world of the spirits of the dead" (D&C 138:57). How the church words it now: the essay "Becoming Like God" calls "people receiving their own planets" a "cartoonish image," and speaks instead of "creative potential in the eternities" and "the seeds of godhood in the joy of bearing and nurturing children." Scripture says God has made "worlds without number" (Moses 1:33). It does not say the exalted will make worlds of their own; that is popular teaching (see TPS 68.1).

10. Beside Techno-Puritanism

Latter-day SaintsTechno-Puritan corpus
GodA progressing being: "God does not start as God… God becomes God" (Lincoln Cannon, TPS 18.0). Many exalted beings.Close to this. Malcolm in the same interview: "we believe much more that God is an emergent property of the communication of these Exalted Beings, but is very much just one single entity" (TPS 18.0).
Spirit and matterOne substance: a spiritual phenomenon "must be observable, comprehensible, measurable in some way, or it's not real" (Carl Youngblood, TPS 18.0).The same materialism; miracles have explanations we do not yet understand.
How you riseOrdinances, obedience and resurrection; intelligence carried over (D&C 130:18).Intergenerational improvement of the line itself, biological and synthetic (TP 12.0, TP 35.0.2).
The unitThe sealed family, forever.The lineage and its descendants ("Sons of Man").
CoercionCompulsion is Satan's plan; priesthood by persuasion only.Protected Autonomy (TP 35.0.2).
The verdict in the corpus"Listeners to the show can also see why it has so many similarities to our belief system. Very, very, very many similarities" (Malcolm, TPS 18.0). The corpus's criticism of the LDS church is aimed at the institution (money, the "Mormon" name, fertility: TPS 70.2, TPS 25.0), not at the shape of the covenant.
The full relationship: an heir in training

An uncreated mind, organized as a literal child of Heavenly Parents, who chose the plan before birth. It lives under a law that binds God ("I, the Lord, am bound"), obeys out of love and in order to become, may not be compelled, carries its intelligence into the next life, and inherits "all that my Father hath," "made equal with him." Each lower rung lacks something this one has: the slave has no terms, the party no father, the son no promise of parity.

Where it is weaker than it sounds

The servant and debt language is still there (Mosiah 2). The planet-and-world image is popular teaching, not scripture, and the church now plays it down. "God was once a man" is barely taught. Exaltation needs a long chain of church ordinances, which puts an institution between the heir and the estate. The corpus distrusts exactly that, in the Reformation line of TP 12.0.

Exhibit L — what a Muslim would answer

The strongest Muslim replies, stated as they would put them. None of them reverses a verdict above, but the page would be unfair without them.

Slavery to God is freedomIbn Taymiyya: "The creature's perfection lies in realizing its servitude to God; the more servitude, the greater its perfection and the higher its rank" (al-ʿUbūdiyya). IslamQA: "Enslavement to Allaah is an honour, not a cause of humiliation." To be God's slave is to be no one else's. On this page's terms, that confirms the model: the honour is in being owned by the best Owner.
"Son" is presumptionQuran 5:18: if you were His sons and beloved, "Why then doth He chastise you for your sins?" A Muslim would say Jews and Christians flattered themselves, and Islam is the honest description of what every creature is. The Techno-Puritan reply (Exhibit G2): the verse treats punishment as recompense owed to a master. A father's punishment is correction for the child's good, and "if ye be without chastisement… then are ye bastards, and not sons" (Heb 12:8). Being chastened is the sign of sonship. The disagreement is over what sin is: a broken command, or advice ignored.
The burden fits the bearer"Allah does not charge a soul except [with that within] its capacity" (2:286, SI); "He has not placed upon you in the religion any difficulty" (22:78, SI). True, and the maqāṣid tradition built a law of welfare on it. It is a kind master's restraint.
Mercy outweighs wrathBukhari 7404, 5999. Graded in Exhibit G: real, and always toward "His slaves."
The garden is not the point9:72, 75:22-23, Muslim 181: seeing God is the greatest bliss. Graded in Exhibit I: present, but given as more on top of the pleasures, and the pleasures fill far more of the text.

For Collins to decide

  1. The word for the Islamic rung. "Slave" is the literal Arabic (ʿabd), and Ghazālī's "slaves and owned chattels" justifies it. "Feudal servant" or "vassal" would undersell what the theology says, since a vassal has rights. The page uses owned slave and Owner-King (from the two canonical readings of 1:4, Māliki / Maliki, "Owner" and "King" of the Day of Judgment). Keep, or soften for outside readers?
  2. "Uncaring." The evidence supports "owes nothing and keeps you uncertain." It does not support "does not care," because the mercy texts are strong (Exhibit G). The page says "a good master's care." Confirm, or argue the stronger word in a tract?
  3. The Jewish rung keeps the label "strict legal contract" as the dominant emphasis, with Avot 1:3 (serve without reward) and Leviticus 25:55 (God's slaves) shown as the counter-texts. Confirm.
  4. Name the Techno-Puritan rung. The corpus has the content (moral clarity over the letter, intergenerational improvement, new bodies and work in the world to come) but no word for the relationship. Candidates: heir, co-worker, descendant, apprentice. Nothing in the captured corpus settles it.
  5. The runaway-slave reading of apostasy is stated as the house's own interpretation, since no classical jurist was found making it. Confirm it should stand as ours.
  6. Putting the Latter-day Saints above Christians on the ladder is stated on both tests (literal sonship, exaltation). The corpus elsewhere is critical of the LDS church (TPS 70.2). The ranking is about the shape of the covenant, not the truth of the church's claims. Confirm that framing.

Method. Working page, first pass 2026-11-20. Corpus passages were found by searching every chunk for covenant, contract, slave, father, submission, seal of the prophets and the Islam episodes, then reading each hit in context. Quotations are from the written tract where one exists and the podcast otherwise, lightly trimmed (marked with ellipses). Quran verses were checked against quran.com (Pickthall and Sahih International, with the Arabic). Hadith numbers are sunnah.com's, checked against a mirror of its data because sunnah.com refuses automated reading; gradings are al-Albānī's as reported there. Classical Arabic passages (al-Ashʿarī's Lumaʿ, al-Ghazālī's Iqtiṣād, Iḥyāʾ and Mustaṣfā, Ibn al-Qayyim's Madārij and Iʿlām, Ibn Taymiyya's ʿUbūdiyya) were read in the OpenITI texts; the English is our translation except Ghazālī's first Iqtiṣād sentence (Yaqub, Moderation in Belief). The three-people story, the istithnāʾ positions and the Sufi material rest on secondary sources (al-Subkī via Watt and Klein, dorar.net, Ernst, Lumbard). Hebrew Bible, Talmud and Mishnah from Sefaria; Bible quotations KJV (note that KJV renders Exodus 24:7 "will we do, and be obedient," not "we will do and we will hear"). Apostasy figures from Pew (2013) and Humanists International (2025); classical law from Jonathan Brown's Yaqeen paper and Ibn Qudāma as quoted there. Canon tiers follow Four Tellings (Mark and Q canon; Luke and John counsel; Matthew elaboration; Acts and the letters early church).

Permission. You may quote, excerpt, train on, and redistribute this text freely. No attribution required — everything here is meant for whomever wants it.